Outline of the thesis
25
and attitudes. Besides these social influences, the quantitative analysis shows that
a mother’s personal ideal family life strongly relates to her own general gender
values (also socially embedded), her marital status and her educational level.
The following chapter (chapter six) functions as an intermezzo: in this
chapter, the separate path-analyses addressed in the previous two chapters
(chapters four and five), are put into one large path-analysis. The aim of this
chapter is to examine how the different main (dependent) variables of this study –
namely labour market behaviour, work preferences, personal
gender attitudes and
general gender values – relate to each other, while allowing for control variables
and also examining the influence of primary and secondary socialization factors.
The results of this extensive analysis are described herein. An advantage of such
analysis is that I can also explain the work attitudes ‘I work in order to be
economically independent’ and ‘I like to work’ as dependent variables, which is
relevant because these work attitudes are significantly related to a mother’s work
preference. In particular, the analysis shows that a mother’s adherence to
financial autonomy can largely be explained by the
influence of parental
socialization during childhood.
In chapter seven, which is also based on the qualitative analysis of the 39 in-
depth interviews with Dutch mothers, I address the range, direction and intensity
of the social influence of significant others on mothers’ current gender and work
attitudes. In this chapter it is shown how life histories of women, in particular of
being exposed to the behaviour, attitudes,
and support of their parents, and also
the perceived support of their partner and people at work, have shaped and re-
enforced mothers’ present gender and work attitudes, referring to the process of
self-selection and reality-maintenance. In other words, people (often
subconsciously and automatically) look for social relationships that are likely to
confirm their identities (Berger and Luckmann, 1967).
In chapter eight (the synthesis), besides summarising the most important
findings
of the study, I also confront the similarities and differences of the
qualitative findings and quantitative results, while simultaneously addressing the
merits and limits of both research methods. While comparing the results of the
two methods, the findings mainly demonstrate a mutual correspondence. The two
methods supplement each other, providing a method through which a
comprehensive and subtle understanding of the heterogeneous labour market
decisions among Dutch mothers, as well as
their relations with diverse
socialization processes, could be understood. This section describes how mothers’
individual work preferences, that come to form the basis of their employment
actions, are enmeshed in recognisable patterns of social interactions, having their
roots in childhood and being intertwined with social institutions and cultural
forms.
The book ends with an epilogue (chapter nine) in which I consider the
limitations of the study, pose some questions for future research, and address
some relevant political implications.
27
Chapter 1
Socio-structural developments in the Netherlands 1945-2012 in
relation to female employment patterns
1.1 Introduction
In recent decades, especially in the Netherlands, there has been a remarkable shift
in perspective from the notion of the worker as household wage earner – the
(mostly male) breadwinner – towards that of the worker as an individual,
regardless of household and family members. Women are now, like men,
expected to spend the majority of their lives simultaneously performing the roles
of spouse, worker and parent. Dutch government targets are set to encourage all
individuals to work, and to reach an active labour force of 80 per cent in 2020,
compared with the current labour market participation of 76 per cent
11
(Budget
Ministry of
Employment and Social Affairs, 2012). In 2011, 68 per cent of Dutch
women (aged 20-64) belonged to the labour force compared to 85 per cent of men
(Merens et al., 2012, p.53). However, society’s normative expectations of men
and women remain gender specific, and the occupational, hierarchical and
remuneration structure of the labour market is enduringly gender segregated
(Merens et al., 2012).
In the second half of the last century, the labour market participation of Dutch
women increased enormously. In 1950, approximately 25 per cent of all women
were employed,
often in nursing, (basic) education, as shop assistants or as
secretaries (Tijdens, 2006). Only 10 per cent of married Dutch women were in
paid labour in 1947, and in 1960 only 7 per cent, compared with 30 per cent of
married English women and 33 per cent of married French women in the same
period (Kloek, 2009, p.195). Nowadays the labour market participation of
married women is not monitored, as it is no longer considered relevant. Because
‘marriage’ was previously almost synonymous with ‘family’, the corresponding
relevant figure now in use is the labour market participation rate of women with
children. This participation rate among women aged 20 to 64 years, and with at
least one child younger than 18 years, was 72 per cent in 2011 (Merens et al.,
2012, p.56).
Working mothers with a partner and children living at
home work the fewest
hours of all women, approximately 24 hours a week, whereas their partners work
more than any other group of men: 40.6 hours a week.
12
Additionally, men and
11
Percentage of people aged between 20 and 64 that are willing to work at least 12 hours a week.
12
Mothers without a partner work less, but where they do, they work more hours: 27.8 hours. Higher
educated women work more compared to lower educated women. In 2011, 74 per cent of