Workshop: Legal aspects of free and open source software
____________________________________________________________________________________________
83
Buying proprietary solutions in purchasing centres to provide solutions at lower
costs and a support service; and
Formalising work processes for the local government.
IMIO provides its software and services to any municipality of the Walloon region, which
can become member of the project. Currently, it is partly financed by subsidies of the
Walloon region, and partly by the prices paid by the members for each “product”. These
prices are linked to the number of inhabitants of the municipality. The solutions proposed
by IMIO can be deployed on the infrastructures of their members or made available in
"SaaS Software as a Service" from IMIO’s infrastructure.
3.5.2 Results
IMIO has currently more than 180 members, amongst which more than half of the Walloon
municipalities (150 out of 262 – the 30 remaining members being other types of public
services such as public social action centres).
IMIO benefits from Walloon Region subsidies (1.2 Million Euro at its launch), but has
already reached a turnover of about 1 Million Euro in 2012. It is expected to become fully
sustainable within a few years.
According to Joël Lambilotte (co-founder of CommunesPlone and employee of IMIO) “the
IMIO initiative is successful and the results are better than what was predicted in the
business plan. The success comes from the “official” status of the organisation as a publicly
owned entity. A second success factor is certainly the experience gathered from the field
with the CommunesPlone project, whose debut dates back to 2005. The partnership with
many technological SME’s has also provided an undeniable advantage comparing to other
solutions available on the Market. These elements bring a very hands-on and bottom-up
approach to the global strategy”.
3.5.3 Features
ACTION:
Policy (joint action of several local PA)
DECISION LEVEL: Local (Walloon region & municipalities)
ACTION LEVEL:
Local (Walloon municipalities)
OBJECTIVE:
To foster the mutualising of local administration software
MEASURES
TAKEN: Creation of a public company which
procures, develops, maintains, supports and mutualises
software for the local municipalities.
LICENSING:
Open source software (GPL is mainly involved)
EFFECTIVENESS:
The initiative seems successful and reaching its objectives.
It is too early to assess its sustainability.
3.6. France: Circular on the use of open source in the
administration
3.6.1 General
presentation
On 19 September 2012, the French Prime Minister Jean-Marc Ayrault addressed a circular
to all the French ministers inviting them to implement the guidelines on the use of free
software in the administration
165
prepared by the DISIC (Direction Interministérielle des
Systèmes d’Information et de Communication).
The guidelines start from the statement that “from now on, in order to meet business
needs, Free Software must be considered on equal footing with other solutions”. After some
introductory explanations on the basic features of FOSS and its licensing scheme, its model
based on services and its advantages in different contexts, the guidelines broadly describe
165
“Usage du logiciel libre dans l’administration”, annexed to the circulaire 56/SG of 19 september 2012, available
at
http://circulaire.legifrance.gouv.fr/pdf/2012/09/cir_35837.pdf
. An english translation made by the APRIL is
available at
http://www.april.org/en/french-prime-minister-instructions-usage-free-software-french-
administration
.
Policy Department C: Citizens' Rights and Constitutional Affairs
____________________________________________________________________________________________
84
eight inter-ministerial action lines aiming at facilitating the use of Free Software solutions in
the administration's choices and at levelling the playing field, while at the same time
achieving maximum economic efficiency and quality:
Instituting an effective convergence on certain Free Software projects. A
convergence framework is established, which aims at selecting and focussing some
relevant FOSS that can be developed and reused in State information systems. Each
ministry must participate in its updating and progressive reinforcing.
Activating networks of experts, which gather specialists from the different ministries
and aim at sharing expertises and competences. This includes the organisation of
inter-ministerial workgroups and public workshops and conferences.
Improving Free Software support in a controlled economic context. The objective is
to centralise and to mutualise support and maintenance services amongst the
ministries.
Contributing in a coordinated way to chosen free software projects. The government
plans to financially endorse Free Software development by systematically re-
injecting from 5 to 10 percent of the avoided licensing costs in the development
process.
Keeping in contact with the large communities. “Just as software editors maintain
regular contact with all ministries, to update knowledge of their products, be able to
anticipate their changes, and even assess needs, it is essential to have links to large
communities such as the Mozilla Foundation or the Document Foundation. However,
as these foundations do not have a commercial approach, the logic is reversed. It is
the administration that must regularly contact them”, the document explains.
Deploying credible and operational alternatives to the large software editors'
solutions. The aim is to identify and focus on credible alternatives and foster their
adoption.
Mapping out use of FOSS and its impacts. Annual analyses on FOSS adoption should
be carried out and published.
Developing a culture of use of Free Software licenses in the development of public
information systems. This last point acknowledges and aims at addressing the
“complex management of code ownership”. It provides that “the State must
safeguard its ability to release code in a manner that maximizes its own benefit,
regardless of which provider did the development. The State must therefore make
use, or prepare the use, of Free Software licenses, be they permissive or not,
depending on the context. It must also ensure that this freedom prevails vis-à-vis its
suppliers in every context that could lead to reuse, unless explicit additional costs
are generated”.
To achieve all these results, some concrete action lines are planed:
a network of experts is established among lawyerss/purchasers involved
in the drafting of specifications and administrative clauses;
specific training courses are set up within ministries: fast-track ones for
project managers and developers, more in-depth ones for lawyers and
buyers;
provider liability clauses and obligations must also be added when said
providers use or develop Free Software code, and
licence management must be one of the components of the explicit IT
governance within each ministry.
It is noticeable that, in order to add legitimacy to the guidelines, reference is made to the
Council of State’s decision of 30 September 2011
166
, which confirmed that a public
166
Conseil d’Etat, Decision n°350431 of 30 September 2011, available at
http://arianeinternet.conseil-
etat.fr/arianeinternet/getdoc.asp?id=192208&fonds=DCE&item=1
.
Dostları ilə paylaş: |