Course-5 Understanding Disciplines and School Subjects pmd

The Chronology of Formation of Disciplines
Disciplines inadvertently have been around as long as humans have been learning
from each other. Of course, this knowledge exchange was not labelled. The earliest
recording of an academic discipline, similar to the ones we know today, was with the Greeks
in Socrates’ time. During this time and extending closer to the present, education was strictly
for the upper class. Also, during this time, education was religion-and military-
centered versus the disciplinary-focused curriculum we know today.
The 1800’s started to see the development of the modern disciplinary systems we
know. The disciplines that we know today started as scholars specializing in that field of
interest then continuing to share their knowledge with others. The scholars who have
specialized in particular topics would collaborate together to determine definitions for the
40

---

field of study in order to create the disciplines. As knowledge along with communities
grew, the need for professions grew as well, and these communities and professions carved
out the academic disciplines.
Kenneth (1974) observes that like any other social phenomena academic disciplines
do have a history. Every discipline can be analysed by looking at its historical development.
Historians of science can look at the specific historical conditions that led to the foundation
of an academic discipline and at how it changed over time, or in other words, its evolution.
The historical perspective helps to understand the great continuity of disciplines, but also
the points of discontinuity or departure from obsolete practices and ways of thinking.
Sometimes this leads to the disappearance of an older discipline and the creation of a new
one that can replace it. In other words, the historical perspective captures the great dynamics
of the development of science and the academic disciplines.
Historians will generally look for the wider societal context and the overall conditions
that influenced the development of a specific discipline, for example the political climate
or any particular needs society had at a particular time, as well as internal factors that
shaped its development. For example, Julie (1990) has pointed out that the academic
discipline was an invention of the late Middle Ages. The term was first applied to three
academic areas for which universities had the responsibility of producing trained
professionals: theology, law and medicine. Julie argues that this early disciplining of
knowledge was a response to external demands, while the specialization into disciplines
that emerged in the 19th century was due to internal reasons.
How does a new discipline emerge?
The formation of a new discipline requires talented scientists who can take over the
burden of intellectual leadership by defining what the new discipline is about and by giving
it a clear agenda for research, which can inspire followers. In other words, finding a new
discipline needs adventurous pioneers who are willing to leave their original discipline
behind and to cover new ground, which always includes a certain risk that they and their
new discipline will possibly fail.
This means that practically every new discipline starts off necessarily as an
interdisciplinary project that combines elements from some parent discipline(s) with original
new elements and insights. Once the discipline is established a new type of researcher is
needed. The new discipline needs people who can consolidate it by filling in the gaps left
by the pioneers. Without these consolidators and synthesizers, a discipline will never develop
some stable identity and will eventually go nowhere. So, in the consolidation phase
disciplines will start restricting too original ideas and will become more and more focused
on disciplinary coherence and orthodoxy.
41

---

Arthur L. Dirks (1996) gives a comprehensive account of the development of the
academic disciplines. The following time-line shows the history of disciplines during the
course of time.
Pythagoras’ Museum in the 500 BC cultivated studies of mathematics, music,
acoustics, and geometry. Other inquiry was pursued by the Sophists, who established the
oratorical tradition, but were itinerant teachers. Socrates, advocated his questioning method
of provoking discovery. In 392 BC, Isocrates established a rhetorical school in Athens to
train students in politics. In 387 BC, Plato opened his Academy in Athens. Mathematics
and music were some of the first disciplines that were taught in the Greek era. When Plato
opened his academy, he taught social issues such as politics and education alongside the
already established discipline of mathematics. His standard studies included Pythagorean
number theory, advanced geometry and speculations on science. He explored social issues,
primarily, education, jurisprudence, politics, and sex. Aristotle founded his Lyceum in 335
BC in Athens, which resembled the Academy, but was wider in intellectual scope. There
was little that escaped discussion: music, botanical classification, biology, anthropology,
ethics, law, logic, metaphysics, physics, politics, psychology, poetry, rhetoric. In
Constantinople, Theodosius II founded a university in the 400s where the subjects ranged
from grammar, letters, medicine, and law to philosophy. By the golden era of Islamic culture
in the 1000s, curricula covered a broad range including mathematics (algebra, geometry,
and trigonometry), science (chemistry, physics, and astronomy), medicine (anatomy, surgery,
pharmacy, and specialized medicine), philosophy (logic, ethics, and metaphysics), literature
(philology, grammar, poetry, and prosody), social sciences, history, geography, politics,
law, sociology, psychology, jurisprudence, and theology (comparative religions, history of
religions, study of the Koran, religious traditions, and other religious subjects). In medieval
world, there existed only four main faculties for study. They were Medicine, Theology,
Liberal Arts and Canon Law. In the contemporary period the number of studied disciplines
increased greatly. From the middle of the nineteenth century, such rather new disciplines as
non-classical languages, political science, literature, and economics were added. Besides,
as there were made many discoveries in natural science and technology disciplines,
42