Chapter 7 - Exploring the social biographical patterns of Dutch mothers’ attitudes
179
Nonetheless, the story of Michelle’s youth already revealed that her parents’
somewhat “ruthless” upbringing style almost inevitably encouraged her to
become a very independent woman.
In the stories of the interviewees, it emerges that the influence of close friends
on the gender attitudes of mothers seems less than expected. Mothers even
hesitate to describe the gender attitudes of their best friends. Sometimes, this was
because they were reluctant to speak for other people, but other times this was
because they simply did not know. This is revealed through
the following quote
from Sheila:
“I suspect that sometimes they think ‘gee, why does she work so much?’ I
think that, yes.” (Sheila, 37 years old, 2 children, 36 hours, egalitarian,
intermediate education).
A reason for this lack of knowledge is that most women identify their best
friends as the ones they have known since high school or later educational years.
Since their youth, mothers and their close friends have experienced a great deal
together, such as graduations, weddings, funerals, and the birth of their children.
At present, these old and dearest friends often do not pursue the same lifestyles as
the mothers themselves, for example because these friends
are without partners or
children. In addition, most mothers confess that they do not see their best friends
much, due to the time commitments of work and children, and sometimes because
their friends live in other areas of the country or abroad. And when they do meet
up, it is mainly to catch up, so the marital division of labour or concrete work
schedules are then not main topics of their conversations.
Often mothers
have also made new friends, for example those they have met
at their child’s school, or else at work. Although mothers are careful when
describing these new friends as ‘close’, these new friends tend to have more
similarities with their own current lifestyles, and ‘everyday’ contact makes it
easier to discuss more everyday subjects, such as household quarrels and
grievances.
As a consequence, it seems that mothers have a more mutual
influential relationship with these new friends.
The social pressure of other people in their social environment, other mothers
in particular, is also discussed by the respondents. It appears that if mothers
behave in line with the current Dutch norm, which implies a working week
of
about three days (Portegijs et al., 2008b), then mothers’ narratives reveal how
much their life style is socially accepted.
“My sister in law says that I have it perfect, because I still develop myself, I
am not completely out of the labour market, and at home I can also be very
much present too.” (Nel, 32 years old, 1 child, 16 hours, traditional/adaptive,
university degree).
However, in the case of mothers who do not suit the current Dutch norm –
either due to being a stay-at-home mother or working full-time – the social
atmosphere is less accepting. This affects in particular mothers who do not work.
Socialized Choices - Labour Market Behaviour of Dutch Mothers
180
“The general hip and trendy working women, you know, I feel they have their
opinion ready. I often want to shout: ‘You don’t know what it’s like, woman,
to have twins!’“ (Janne, 38 years old, 3 children, stay-at-home mother,
traditional/adaptive, higher polytechnic).
“Sometimes it is very difficult because you feel the pressure from outside.
People ask me: ‘So what do you do all day?’ They think I drink coffee the
whole day.” (Mireille, 35 years old, 3 children, stay-at-home mother,
adaptive, secondary school).
Mothers with egalitarian gender attitudes seem to be less affected by the
weaker social circle:
“You know when you work, you are not concerned with the mothers in the
schoolyard. What people think of me there has never interested me at all,
really. I don’t care. No, I even refuse to be sensitive to that.” (Claire, 47 years
old, 2 children, 36 hours, egalitarian, university degree).
Nonetheless, also among egalitarian mothers one can perceive a pattern that
they rather live in social environments that match their own norms and attitudes.
If norms and values of the neighbourhood differ too much from their own,
mothers (and their families)
seem impelled to move away, because they did not
feel at ease, of which Cathy (44 years old, 2 children, 32 hours, egalitarian,
university degree) gives an example:
“Yes, when we had our son, we decided to live outside Amsterdam. But there,
I felt the worst mother ever. He was the only one from school who went to
after-school care. He was picked up in a little van and went to another
village. All the kids went home for lunch… lunch! Drama - I felt terrible.”
(Cathy and her partner subsequently decided to move back to Amsterdam).
Hence, mothers do seem sensitive to real and supposed expectations, and to
the approval of other people. It is difficult however to perceive whether and to
what extent these social influences and subsequent feelings affect mothers’
attitudes. Nonetheless, the narratives reveal that people do not haphazardly end
up in matching social environments.
The influence of supervisors does seem to have a discerning relationship with
the gender attitudes of mothers. In particular, higher-educated mothers with
egalitarian attitudes tend to recall positive experiences with supervisors who had
a re-enforcing and stimulating influence on
their career aspirations, above all
because they got the chance to show the best of themselves.
“I am always stimulated by my supervisors. Once they even offered me a job
when I was pregnant.” (Ilse, 43 years old, 3 children, 40 hours, egalitarian,
university degree).
“My former publisher, he is no longer at our company, but we still have
contact. He always gives me a lot of energy when I talk to him about my