R E S E A R C H E S O N M A L A R I A
89
of station to which my family and myself had been subject; and if I were now
compelled to return to Secunderabad, I should not be able later to pay for my
passage to England. Moreover, both Daniels and Rivenburg were now leav-
ing me, and it was evidently foolish to expect any further assistance in India-
much more that of a trained entomologist, which I especially required for the
completion of my work on human malaria. I therefore determined to leave
India forthwith and to return to England, trusting to fortune to give me an
opportunity for finishing the investigation in a manner which I thought suit-
able. I mention these personal details as I have been blamed for leaving India
at that moment.
Before doing so, I urged upon Government the importance of taking active
measures for the prevention of malaria in accordance with my observations.
Besides advising the strict use of mosquito-nets for a personal prophylaxis, I
urged especially a campaign against mosquitoes as the best measure for towns
and cantonments, particularly against the dappled-winged mosquitoes, which
I said breed principally in water on the ground. My letter was published
later
55
, and I hope that the advice will soon begin to be taken.
I had also written a brief abstract of my work dated the 31st December,
1898. This was presented by Laveran to the Académie de Médecine on the
24th January, 1899, and was published soon afterwards
55
. In this paper my
obligations to Manson and Laveran were acknowledged, I hope, in the full
manner which honourable science demands. I wrote :
"Pour éviter tout commentaire erroné, qu’il me soit permis de déclarer ici
que mes travaux ont été entiérement dirigés par Manson, et que j’ai eu l’as-
sistance de ses conseils et de son influence à toute occasion; je dois aussi re-
mercier le Dr. Laveran de m’avoir envoyé ses avis si autorisés. Quand, en mai
dernier, je lui envoyai des spécimens de mes corps pigmentés du moustique,
il reconnut immédiatement la vraie nature de ces éléments."
And I added in conclusion,
"Je considère comme probable que la malaria est communiquée á l’homme
uniquement par les morsures des moustiques et peut-être d’autres insectes."
21. England (March-July, 1899). Foundation of the Liverpool School of Tropical
Medicine.
On the voyage to England (February 1899) I had full time to con-
sider the present condition of our knowledge about malaria, especially in rela-
tion to the all-important subject of prevention. It was almost certain that in-
fection is caused solely by the bites of insects - but of what insects only? My long
90
1 9 0 2 R .R O S S
negative work had almost proved that the
commonest Indian mosquitoes, the
grey and brindled genera, do not carry aestivo-autumnal infection, at least. On
the other hand, it was certain that two species of dappled-winged mosquitoes
in Secunderabad, and one species in Rome, do carry it; while, if Bignami’s
observation was to be trusted, the last species carries also the mild tertian infec-
tion. But Secunderabad and Rome are not the whole world; even in Bengal,
Daniels and I had not succeeded in infecting dappled-winged mosquitoes. The
question as to which species do or do not carry malaria might prove to be a
very complex one, not to be solved only by a few local experiences; there
are probably hundreds of species of mosquitoes in the world, each of which
would have to be tested unless we could find some good reason for limiting
the enquiry. I therefore sought for some such reason, and found one. For cen-
turies it had been known that malaria is connected with stagnant water on the
ground - not with water in the pots, tubs, and tanks which abound close to all
habitations, but with marshes and pools on the surface of the earth. Again
malaria was known to increase every year at the rainy season, and subsoil-
drainage was known to mitigate if not remove the disease. Hence it was ex-
tremely probable that the insects which carry malaria breed only, or chiefly, in terrestial
water.
For years we had assumed that the disease is caused by organisms which
spring from marshes. We had been partially right, but not wholly right; it is
not the infective but the infecting organism which springs from the marsh -
not the germ but the carrier of the germ. Now, referring to mosquitoes alone,
which varieties of these insects breed only or chiefly in terrestial waters? I re-
membered my frequent observations on this point (sections 14, 15, and 19).
The grey and brindled mosquitoes breed chiefly in tubs and pots in India; but
the dappled-winged mosquitoes breed in pools on the ground.
Now it was only these
last which, hitherto, had certainly been connected experimentally with ma-
laria.*
What a weapon for good was now placed in our hands! Hitherto when we
wished to remove malaria we were obliged to drain a whole area, recognizing
only that all terrestial waters seemed to be dangerous. Now we should be able
to go to a place and to point out the actual pools which cause the disease, by
showing that they contain the larvae of the culpable insects. The expense of
dealing only with these would be much less.
Shortly after my arrival in England in March I learnt something about the
zoological classification of mosquitoes from Mr. E. E. Austen of the British
* This reasoning was by no means obvious or even known until after our work at Sierra
Leone. In temperate climates grey mosquitoes (Culex) also breed often in terrestial water.