Scheme of work – Buddhism



Yüklə 141,04 Kb.
tarix27.10.2018
ölçüsü141,04 Kb.



Scheme of work – Buddhism

This scheme of work for A-level Religious Studies (7062) is designed to help you plan your teaching.



Assumed coverage

This scheme of work is based on 90 guided learning hours.

It allows eight weeks for the Year 1 AS content and a further eight weeks for the Year 2 content, leaving approximately four weeks for Dialogues.

Sources of wisdom and authority


Week

Learning activities

Resources

1–2

Understand the significance of the Buddha’s life to Buddhism underpins most/all discussions on the relevance of the Buddha as a role model and his authority as ‘the enlightened one’ for Buddhists.

Check prior learning: class activity designing a symmetrical Buddha image and labelling up the different parts of the image; this can function as an ice breaker.

Split class into groups to do independent research on different parts of the Buddha’s life – Buddha’s birth stories, his early life, the four signs and his ascetic life and the Buddha’s enlightenment. Report back to the whole class.

Dialogues: Buddha’s enlightenment experience as an example of religious experience. How far can this be seen as a reliable source of ‘proof’?

Divide a page into four. Use headings such as ‘Disguised Dukkha’; ‘Obvious Dukkha worldwide’; ‘Human crimes’; ‘Natural disasters’ and then fill in the quartered chart. Students could also include examples of when the Buddha encountered dukkha in his early life and after he left the palace, eg

his encounter with Devadatta, his cousin and the swan

the ploughing match

the Four Sights

Kisa Gotami and the mustard seed story

meeting Angulimala.

They could also look at contrasting views of the differing beliefs about the Buddha’s teaching between Theravada and Mahayana Buddhism.

Paired or small group work considering the question about whether or not Buddhism is pessimistic in its outlook on life. The seven well known states of dukkha as well as how dukkha links to the other two marks of existence, anatta and anicca.

Explanation of ‘skilful means’ or ‘skill – in – means’ and its impact as a teaching for Mahayana Buddhists

Learn the parable of the Burning House and its meaning through discussion in class. They can then do a modern version of their own as a way of remembering the moral/meaning of the parable.

Independent research:

different Buddhist scriptures

oral tradition versus written tradition

consideration of whether an oral or written tradition is more authentic/reliable for Buddhist followers

research on how the Pali Canon is used in Buddhist worship and daily life (links to unit on Worship)

Differentiation and extension: preparation of questions for a debate centred on whether or not it matters if scriptures were first transmitted orally or written down in terms of their authenticity.

Dialogues: do beliefs and teachings that come from scripture have authority? How does this relate to religious experience?


buddhanet.com

Skilful means in Lotus Sutra

Parable of the burning house

palicanon.org



Ultimate reality

Week

Learning activities

Resources

3–4

Discuss contrasting thoughts about the Buddha between Theravada and Mahayana schools of Buddhism:

Theravada sticks firmly to the notion of a historical Buddha that lived some 80 years and died and left the Dharma for his followers

the Mahayana tradition in contrast sees the Buddha on different levels and the Trikaya doctrine (Dharmakaya; Sambhogakaya and Nirmanakaya) which encompasses these thoughts was developed over a period of time.

Construct a chart that shows the threefold relationship of the Trikaya and students can add any additional material to a box or ‘cloud’ design as they research more about each part of the Trikaya.

Consider the meaning and importance of the concept of Anicca; Anicca can operate on many levels such as the animate and the inanimate as well as the level of our minds.

Students to think of as many words for ‘impermanence’ as they can and have a class based activity contributing to a round robin of ideas.

Students give examples of how anicca can be seen to operate in:

the animate world; with anything living

the inanimate world; anything non-living

our minds; ideals, notions, views that may change over time.

Explore how anicca can relate to dukkha and anatta; the other two that make up the three signs of being or three marks of our existence, ie how anicca can cause dukkha. Students can give some examples.

Discuss: from the standpoint of enlightenment, the doctrine of emptiness or sunyata is the reality of all worldly existences, ie it is the skilful means that disentangle Buddhists from defilement and unsatisfactoriness. The realisation of sunyata leads Buddhists to no attachment and clinging.

Students to look up the Prajna Sutra where it says "That which is profound, has sunyata and non-attachment as its significance. No form nor deeds, no rising nor falling, are its implications."

Also in the Dvadasanikaya Sastra (composed by Nagarjuna, translated to Chinese by Kumarajiva A.D. 408) it says: "The greatest wisdom is the so-called sunyata." Both of these texts are useful to make notes from.

Differentiation and extension: which of the three marks of existence is the most important for Buddhists to focus on and why?

Students research some of the key images associated with nirvana and consider why the Buddha often spoke about nirvana in negative terms. They can also invent their own analogies with nirvana.

Use relevant pages from a student text such as Cush, and collect as many adjectives used to describe nirvana as possible.

Differentiation and extension: should nirvana ever be described in picture language? Give reasons for your answer.



buddhanet.net

Sunyata

Nirvana

Denise Cush, Buddhism

80th dilemma of King Milinda

Self, death and afterlife



Week

Learning activities

Resources

5–6


Cover Nirvana:

the endless cycle of life and death is a flux that can only be stopped by enlightenment, according to Buddhists

enlightenment leads to Nirvana which means the end of all craving, the achievement of perfect non-attachment and of happiness

Nirvana is not a place or a heaven; it is a state of mind that is available to all living beings in this life. It is a way of living and being in the world that is free of suffering and rich in wisdom, happiness and compassion.

Cover Bodhisattva:

the term Bodhisattva refers to someone on the path to Awakening

the Mahayana has conceived them as having renounced the ultimate state out of pure compassion towards all beings, and can therefore refers to anyone en route

in Theravada Buddhism, it usually refers either to Maitreya, the Buddha of the Future, or to the historical Buddha Gautama prior to his enlightenment – either during the life in which he became enlightened or in one of the innumerable lives before that in which he was developing the requisite virtues for enlightenment, such as generosity.

Cover Arhat:

when a Buddhist in the Theravada tradition realises that all worldly suffering is caused by craving and that it is possible to bring suffering to an end by following the Noble Eight Fold Path

when that perfected state of insight is reached, ie Nibanna, that person is a ‘worthy person’, an Arhat

the life of the Arhat is the ideal of the followers of this school, ‘a life where all (future) birth is at an end, where the holy life is fully achieved, where all that has to be done has been done, and there is no more returning to the worldly life’.

Students create a chart with Arhat heading the left hand side and Bodhisattva heading the right hand side and note down, from research and lessons the main differences between these two goals of the main two Buddhist traditions.

The Buddhist teaching on anatta or no self or soul should be distinguished from the theory of reincarnation which implies the transmigration of a soul and its invariable material rebirth. Buddhism denies the existence of an unchanging or eternal soul created by a God or emanating from a Divine Essence (Paramatma).

Discuss the Five Skandhas, the Buddhist analysis of personal experience or the Buddhist analysis of the personality. They are the impermanent, ever-changing elements of being that describe the impermanent entity that we label the ’self’.

Students make notes on the meaning of anatta and then read through the Chariot analogy from the Questions of Kind Milinda (King Menander). Devise a modern version of the story and feedback to the class.

Discuss samsara, the circle of suffering that, according to Buddhism is the destiny of all living beings until they achieve enlightenment and break the pattern of rebirth to experience the truth of existence.

Students label up their own copy of the Tibetan Wheel of Life. Arrow point to specific places on the wheel that are highlighted in Buddhist teachings from the centre circle with the three animals representing greed, hatred and delusion to the next circle depicting karma and then the six realms of rebirth followed by dependent origination or the 12 Nidanas. Explanation of the 12 Nidanas and why each symbol in the segment represents what it does on the wheel.

Discuss the Dalai Lama. The current Dalai Lama, Tenzin Gyatso, is the Fourteenth one. Like those before him, he is held to be the reincarnation of the Bodhisattva of Compassion, Avalokitesvara. The concept of reincarnation is fundamental to the continued lineage of the Dalai Lama. This is maintained by the discovery of a young child born soon after the death of a previous Dalai Lama. It is believed that the life-spirit of the deceased transfers to the newly found child, who takes on the pre-ordained mantle of the Dalai Lama.

Dialogues: are any of the claims made about the afterlife, rebirth and the authority of the Dalai Lama as a reincarnation reliable? How could they be verified? Link to Religious Language and views on the soul.



Anatta

Anatta and the four noble truths

Nagasena’s chariot analogy text

King Milinda's questions

The ways of the Arhat and the Bodhisattva

Guanyin

Dalai Lama

buddhanet.net

Wheel of life


Good conduct and key moral principles

Week

Learning activities

Resources

6–7

Understand the five moral precepts:

  1. to undertake the training to avoid taking the life of beings. This precept applies to all living beings not just humans. All beings have a right to their lives and that right should be respected

  2. to undertake the training to avoid taking things not given. This precept goes further than mere stealing. One should avoid taking anything unless one can be sure that is intended that it is for you

  3. to undertake the training to avoid sensual misconduct. This precept is often mistranslated or misinterpreted as relating only to sexual misconduct but it covers any overindulgence in any sensual pleasure such as gluttony as well as misconduct of a sexual nature

  4. to undertake the training to refrain from false speech. As well as avoiding lying and deceiving, this precept covers slander as well as speech which is not beneficial to the welfare of others

  5. to undertake the training to abstain from substances which cause intoxication and heedlessness. This precept is in a special category as it does not infer any intrinsic evil in, say, alcohol itself but indulgence in such a substance could be the cause of breaking the other four precepts.

Divide the class into pairs and each pair take on a presentation of each of the five moral precepts reporting back to the class for a general discussion.

Give students a variety of scenarios and asked what should a Buddhist do if they are following the teachings of the five moral precepts.

A Buddhist who is following the bodhisattva path must cultivate the six perfections of giving or generosity, morality or good conduct, patience, vigour, meditation and wisdom.

Ahimsa is a Pali term for the non-harming or not hurting; gentleness to all forms of life.

Students create a leaflet/chart/booklet on Buddhist responses to each ethical issue making sure they reference 5 precepts, six perfections, ahimsa throughout.

Extension: make links between key beliefs about the self, three marks of existence; samsara and these issues.

Dialogues: how to Buddhist systems of ethics compare to the theories studied in Component 1?


Akusala

Embryo research

Buddhism and abortion

Buddhist perspectives on the abortion debate

Buddhist attitude to animal life

War and peace: a Buddhist perspective

clear-vision.org

BBC: Buddhism

Extension reading on ahimsa: zenpeacemakers.org


Expressions of religious identity

Week

Learning activities

Resources

7–8


Cover the Sangha:

refers primarily to the community of saints and enlightened one's (Ariya Sangha), the third of the three Jewels and the three Refuges, and the order of monks (bhikkhu Sangha) and nuns (bhikkhuni Sangha)

however increasingly the word is now being used for the Buddhist community in general, spiritually developed or not, ordained or not

significance of this third refuge, jewel or treasure in Buddhism.

Students to research:

the five possessions of a monk or nun

the five levels of hierarchy in a Theravadan monastery

the additional five precepts monks and nuns are expected to keep

the three vows

the three promises on entry to the Sangha.

Students could visit a Buddhist monastery such as Amaravati (The Deathless) near Hemel Hempstead, Throssel Hole Abbey (near Hexham), Samye Ling Tibetan Monastery (Dumfriesshire) to get a sense of how Buddhist monks and nuns live in today’s British society.

Chant the morning or evening chant in Pali script with an explanation as a whole class activity.

Focus on Thailand as an example of Theravadan Buddhist practice.

Consider the ‘threefold relationship’ between the King, the people and the Sangha in Thailand. Some background reading on Thailand may be useful. The focus here is on the Sangha and particularly the role it plays in Thai society which is some 96% Theravada Buddhist.

Research on the Wat Phra Dhammakaya movement and feedback to the class.

Define Karma: Merit-making in popular forms of the Buddhist tradition is focused on the belief that actions have spiritual consequences on natural forces and events:

(worship includes) acts directed towards securing worldly prosperity and averting calamities through disease and unseen forces of evil, eg, pirit chanting, bodhi-puja, etc

merit (Pali: punna: Sinh: pin) earned by the performance of a wholesome act is regarded as a sure way of obtaining a better life in the future. The performance of these is also a means of expiation in the sense that the meritorious deeds have the effect of countering and hindering the operation of unwholesome karma previously acquired and inherited. Thus the range of merit is very wide

for the ordinary householder, Nibbana is a goal to be achieved through a gradual process of evolution extending over many lives, and therefore until he achieves that sublime state at some future date he continues to perform these acts in order to lead a happy life. All merit-generating rituals are performed mainly with this end in view.

the operations of karma/kamma/merit are therefore ‘supernatural’ in the sense that it is a force beyond the physical natural world as understood by science. Transfer of ‘merit’ also relevant.

Cover devotion:

in the Mahayana tradition, devotion can be quite elaborate; with a chamber/hall for Sakyamuni Buddha and two disciples, one hall for the 3 Buddhas (including Amitabha and Medicine Buddha) and one hall for the 3 key bodhisattvas; besides the protectors, etc

whereas in the Theravada tradition, it is normally a more simple layout with the image of Sakyamuni Buddha the focus of worship

the focus here is on how Buddhists use a Buddha image or rupa; the importance of worship as well as merit making in the Buddhist tradition.

Cover meditation:

a conscious effort to change how the mind works

the Pali word for meditation is 'bhavana' which means 'to make grow' or 'to develop'

the Buddha taught many different types of meditation, each designed to overcome a particular problem or to develop a particular psychological state

but the two most common and useful types of meditation are Mindfulness of Breathing (anapanasati) and Loving Kindness Meditation (metta bhavana). The focus here is on the nature and purpose of meditation and to avoid generalisations, students need to consider both aspects as well as different types of mediation such as samatha, vipassana, zazen and metta.

Students research the meanings behind right effort; right mindfulness and right concentration on the eightfold path and its significance for Buddhists.

As a follow up to the chanting students could do a stilling exercise in class when they are ‘talked through’ a mediation exercise and then report back to the class on their feelings as this was taking place.

Whole class essay task on ‘Meditation is a waste of time’ or ‘Meditation is just an escape from the real world’ or ‘The benefits of meditation far outweigh the disadvantages’. How far do you agree?



Dhammakaya Foundation

Daily Mail: Buddhist article

BBC: Buddhism

BBC: mindfulness

BBC: Meditation

YouTube: eightfold path

Buddhist ceremonies


Buddhism, gender and sexuality

Week

Learning activities

Resources

9–10

Introduce some background on Thailand and explain the status and role of mae chi/maechi in Thai Buddhism.

Discuss Thai Bhikkunni movement and women’s empowerment; consider the desirability of ordination for women in Thailand and its possible effects of the status of women in society generally.

The final section is on religious movements in contemporary Thailand.

Review the key themes. Students could collate the information into a chart or mind map, and then add links as to how these social factors may influence Buddhist thinking.

Cover the impact of tourism:

increases in both prostitution and HIV/Aids and encouraged sex-trafficking of young girls

exposed both urban and rural communities to examples of western lifestyle and attitudes

the movement to ordain women in Thailand as a ‘Western import’ or ‘western feminist imposition’.

Cover the changing roles of women:

religious specialists are (almost all) male

domestic violence against women, social discrimination and trafficking of girls all reported

women make up 44% of the work force and are entitled to equal pay, there are no legal restrictions on them owning and managing businesses

more than half of university graduates are women

there are some women MPs – numbers increasing

there are employment opportunities as prostitutes in cities – often taken up by girls from poorer regions.

Cover the legal status of women:

1928 – supreme patriarch of Buddhism in Thailand forbids ordination of women. The government revoked this as a secular law sometime after 2003 seeing it as contrary to freedom of religion – however it is still part of the religious law governing the Thai Sangha

1997 – new constitution – Government grants women equality with men. Religious freedom is also now a legal right

however when the first Thai woman was ordained in Sri Lanka as a Bhikkuni (2003), her status was not officially recognised in Thailand but the government did agree not to take action against her

the revival of the Theravad order of nuns in the late 90s involved many obstacles

the requirement for women to be ordained by both ordained monks (bhikkhus) and nuns (bhikkunis). The bhikkuni lineage had died out in Theravada Buddhism many centuries before – so no nuns able to perform ordination.

How can prostitution/the prevalence of HIV and trafficking of women in Thailand be used as arguments in favour of the ordination of women?

Students could examine each fact/situation below in groups and explain why this would be an obstacle to Theravada nuns.

Cover the kammic/karmic deficiency of women:

the perception that birth as a female was evidence of bad kamma. This is linked to the idea that only a man can achieve enlightenment which some claim stems from the Buddha himself – others reject that idea

in Thailand the established role of mae chi/maechi – the serving and supporting role of women in the Sangha; regarded as lay not ordained by the relevant government departments in Thailand so not financially supported.

young boys in Thailand can receive sponsored education as temporary monks; they will be supported by lay donations which, when made to monks are seen as merit making. The support of females serving in the monastic sangha is not seen as merit-making, therefore very limited opportunities for religious education and development for girls.

Cover the evidence in scripture for female ordination:

this suggests initial reluctance from Gautama but then the bhikkuni lineage was started – additional rules for females: 311 rather than 227 (Theravada). See Harvey p298–9

women are to some extent dependent on monks from the beginning. The support of monks for female ordination was essential

the ordination of the first Theravada Bhikkuni required either acceptance that monks could ordain women (the example of Gautama is used to support this) or that nuns from the Mahayana tradition would be acceptable. A Chinese lineage, also found in South Korea and Vietnam, which partly descends from 5th Century Sri Lanka was deemed acceptable by some

1996 – 11 Sri Lankan nuns were ordained in India, by Korean Nuns and Theravada Monks

Sri Lanka 2003 – Dr Chatsurman Kabilsingh (Dhammananda) was ordained as a nun. An intellectual, married with adult children then divorced. She, and her organisation have an international appeal, but she focuses on Thai Buddhism.

Students use website resources to research the life of Dhammananda and produce a social media profile page for her. This could include ‘status updates’ as quotations from her etc.

Questions to consider:

why does Thai, Theravada, Buddhism not allow the ordination of women? What would you see as the greatest stumbling block and why?

what scripture-based arguments are there in favour of female ordination?

why can it be said that the legal status of women in Thailand may encourage the acceptance of female ordination? What changes outside of religion in Thailand may also support this?

what does the work of Dhammananda and the Sakyadhita organisation reveal about the current debate about female ordination and the role of women in Theravada Buddhism?

why are there different views about female ordination in Buddhism? (AO1:3)

are women in Theravada Buddhism inferior to men? (AO2)

explain the influence of Buddhist beliefs on the role of women in Theravada Buddhism (AO1:2)

Debate different Buddhist views about celibacy, marriage and homosexuality. This can range widely across different Buddhist traditions. Core to the debate is the emphasis on celibacy, ‘sensual misconduct’ and tolerance. Things that could be covered:

Theravada Vinaya discipline, celibacy is required as a form of non-attachment. Both heterosexual and homosexual acts are explicitly forbidden.

marriage the appropriate place for sexual activity and child rearing – but note tolerance of prostitution by the Sangha in Thailand, sex need not be confined to marriage

marriage is a secular not a religious institution. Divorce is not a religious matter

the Wikipedia entry on Buddhism and sexual orientation has some useful material on the concepts of pandaka and Ubathovyanjanakas related to homosexuals and transgender issues

some would consider sexual orientation as irrelevant. The issue is the engagement in sexual acts, not the orientation of the individual

the 14th Dalai Lama has expressed concerns over male homosexual acts (1997) but opposes any form of discrimination against homosexual people

The following could form group presentations, a class debate on whether Buddhist attitudes are positive overall, or essay style questions:

what are the key Buddhist ideas about celibacy, marriage, homosexuality and transgender issues – you must include different Buddhist views on each

why are there different views in Buddhism about celibacy and marriage?

why are there different views in Buddhism about homosexuality and transgender issues?

the influence of Buddhist teaching on Buddhist attitudes to celibacy/marriage/ homosexuality and transgender issues.

assess how far Buddhism has a positive attitude to marriage/homosexuality/transgender issues.

Dialogues: how far can Buddhist decision-making be said to be teleological, character-based or deontological?



Harvey P, An introduction to Buddhism, teachings, history and practice, second edition, Cambridge University Press, 2013 pg 300–301, 385–394

Background on Thailand

Thai Bhikkunni movement and women’s empowerment

Social change and religious movements in Thailand

Women in Ocher: Thailand's rebel nuns gain ground

Changing roles of women

Ordination of women in Buddhism

Wikipedia: Buddhism and sexuality

Wikipedia: Buddhism and sexual orientation




Buddhism and science

Week

Learning activities

Resources

11–12

This can be studied alongside the philosophy topic on miracles – miracles are also a topic for dialogue between Buddhism and Christianity; the relationship between scientific and religious discourses is also a dialogue topic.

Such ‘miracles’ indicate the working of a power not recognised by science.

Discuss worship at particular shrines:

apparently rewarded with pregnancy/success/wealth could be seen as ‘miracles’

empirical science has no room for such ‘spiritual’ forces – it provides alternative empirical explanations and/or reasons for denying that the reported events ever happened – this is the challenge of the emphasis on evidence and reason in science.

Discuss responses to the challenge to belief in karma and miracles:

these can be linked to the broader discussion in Buddhism about the relationship between Buddhism and Science

these amount to:

empirical sciences only investigate the apparent world and arrive at conventional truth; there are powers within that world which are evident to the mind but not the senses

Buddhism should drop all its supernatural trappings, including karma and miracles, and present itself as a Way – not as a religious faith.

Advanced reading – researchgate.net

Discuss:

Buddhism as a ‘scientific’ religion – emphasis on reason and evidence: Kalama Sutta

conventional truth and ultimate truth – Thich Nhat Hanh

Buddha’s attitude to ‘unanswerable questions’ – the Parable of the Poisoned Arrow can be interpreted to mean that life is for living and that time spent on speculation about, for example, ultimate origins is pointless.

There is flexibility in the ‘specific discoveries’ that have impacted Buddhism, but some awareness of quantum physics could be very useful in answers.

Cover the key features of quantum physics relevant to Buddhism:

there is constant flux/change at the smallest level beneath the level of ordinary perception; the observer resolves the experience of this change into something that can be described and take form

however the form taken by what is observed depends on the observer – for example light can be wave or particle

our perception of reality is therefore of constant flux that is given form by mind

links to Anicca, Anatta, Samkhara Dukkha and emptiness (legacy specification RSS04 has a section on Quantum and an Eastern worldview which may be useful).

Genetic engineering is the only issue on which questions can explicitly be asked. This links back to Year 1 Ethics work on embryo research and designer babies. The dialogue between ethical studies and Buddhism on this issue is also required for Dialogues questions. A broader introduction may be helpful – abortion, euthanasia etc made possible by science but use of these treatments raises dilemmas – this is also preparation for Dialogues. This allows coverage of how Buddhists make moral decisions re life and death and builds on study of ahimsa in AS/A-level material. There are active Biotech/genetic engineering activities in Thailand – many linked to rice.

Questions to consider:

how/why may science be seen to challenge Buddhism?

how/why may science be seen to support/be consistent with Buddhism?

what value has science for Buddhism? – Consider: science as irrelevant; science as threat and science as support. See also Dialogues question on Additional Specimen paper 2A ‘Science is an enemy of Buddhism’

how/why does science stimulate Buddhist ethical thinking? – use example(s).

Explain the view of Thich Nhat Hanh and the 14th Dalai Lama about the relationship between Buddhism and Science.


Identify different Buddhist responses to genetic engineering (AO1:1) – why are there different Buddhist views? (AO1:3)

Consider the influence of Buddhist teaching on attitudes to genetic engineering (AO1:2). (This is the application of the same information in different contexts)



Buddhist miracles

buddhanet.net

Buddhist view of miracles

Thich Nhat Hanh

Buddhism and science

researchgate.net

Quantum physics and mind

dalailama.com

Genetic engineering: a Buddhist assessment

Genetic engineering: a major threat to vegetarians




Buddhism and the challenge of secularisation

Week

Learning activities

Resources

13–14

The challenges of secularisation: only those mentioned can be required in an answer. The definition of secularisation used simply needs to match the ‘challenges’ identified: the transformation of society from religious to secular.

Discuss:


how, for some, religion has been replaced as a source of truth and moral values: science, humanism and atheism providing replacements; religion seen as irrelevant

relegation of religion to the personal sphere: eg anti realist views of belief

rise of militant atheism: Richard Dawkins if using British context

religion as irrational. Linked to above. Core to the Dialogue debates (Dialogue with Philosophy). Can be taken to mean not based on reason, not consistent with reason/contradicts the evidence. Links to topic on science and religion.

Cover Buddhist responses to materialistic secular values. Note that issues surrounding wealth are specified for study in the Dialogue with Ethics section.

Question to consider: what are ‘materialistic secular values?’ Valuing people by how successful they are in material terms: wealth and possessions. Arguably valuing these can lead to ignoring how they are achieved (eg through deceit and exploitation).

Responses to consider: the example of Gautama: renunciation; The precepts of engaged Buddhism (Thich Nhat Hanh); right livelihood.

Different Buddhist responses to secularisation/living in a secular society:



  1. Amaravati and the preservation of the Forest Tradition

  2. New forms of Buddhism; These can be seen as adaptations to the secular context.

    1. Triratna – the wiki entry on this movement is also useful. Past controversies/scandals are acknowledged on websites such as manchesterbuddhistcentre.org.uk

    2. Secular Buddhism

  3. Engaged Buddhism

Consider services for carers provided by Buddhist organisations. In various places show emphasis on providing them with emotional/mental strength rather than practical help. See

Duscuss the nature of Buddhism: Batchelor and Brazier:

Batchelor: the future of religion transcript

Brazier: interview.

Questions to consider:

how is Buddhism being challenged by secularisation?

what are Buddhist attitudes to wealth and possessions/why are they different/how does Buddhist teaching influence attitudes to wealth and possessions? Note same/similar content applied in different ways.

give two different ways in which Buddhism has responded to the challenge of secularisation – why are there different ways?

why is Buddhism appealing to some as an alternative to other forms of religious expression?

what does Buddhism see as its distinctive contribution to society? What is meant by Engaged Buddhism?

what is Buddhism – compare the ideas of Stephen Batchelor and David Brazier (note: this links forward to next section on diversity in Buddhism and could also draw on that material).


The Guardian: can religion be replaced?

The challenge of secularisation

Richard Dawkins: militant atheism

AC Grayling: 'how can you be a militant atheist? It's like sleeping furiously’

Buddhism on wealth and poverty

Buddhist attitude to wealth

Keown D, A very short introduction to Buddhism, pg 117

amaravati.org

thebuddhistcentre.com

manchesterbuddhistcentre.org.uk

secularbuddhism.org

stephenbatchelor.org

religionfacts.com

accesstoinsight.org

birminghambuddhistcentre.org.uk

The future of religion: a dialogue

The new Buddhism: an interview with David Brazier

David Brazier's 'the new Buddhism'



Buddhism is a Religion: you can believe it, Woodsmoke press, 2014, chapters 1 and 3

Review: Stephen Batchelor’s After Buddhism: rethinking the dharma for a secular age

Stephen Batchelor’s ten theses of secular dharma


Buddhism, migration and religious pluralism

Week

Learning activities

Resources

15–16

There are clear links between this and the previous topic. There are two related dialogue topics – the truth claims of other religions (dialogue with philosophy) and issues of freedom of religious expression (dialogue with ethics).

Cover basic facts of how Buddhism arrived and where it sits in British religious life:

The study of diversity in Britain can only require two contrasting forms of Buddhism and they will already have looked at Amaravati; the selection of at least one other form must allow discussion/evaluation of the claim that Buddhism is a collection of different traditions with little in common. (Secular Buddhism can also be contrasted with Theravada if preferred – could also use a tradition you may have touched elsewhere: Zen, Pure Land, Tibetan)

The features for contrast depend on tradition chosen – Pure Land and Theravada provide ‘easy’ points of contrast – could also treat this more broadly as Theravada/Mahayana but would need to limit content given the very limited testing of AO1 that is possible.

Cover freedom of religion:

as a human right in European Law and religious pluralism as a feature of modern secular states

‘equality’ of religions within a secular context. This will link forward to issues about freedom of religious expression in society.

Buddhist attitudes to religious pluralism; attitudes within Buddhism to other forms of Buddhism/other faiths.

Note pluralism can be taken as the view that there are different, equally valid, approaches to the same goal of which Buddhism is only one and the right of all different religions to exist side by side in a state of tolerance/acceptance.

Cover Nichiren Buddhism: teaches that it is the only true Buddhist tradition.

Discuss concept of conditioned/conventional truth; dangers of attachment to personal views, teaching about tolerance.

Drawing on examples studied above, give examples of freedom of religious expression that may and may not prove controversial, including those that apparently incite violence; Muslim/Buddhist relations in both Sri Lanka and Myanmar may also be referenced (Sri Lanka link above). This could include a discussion about how far ahimsa can allow tolerance of anything that causes harm.

Research diversity of Buddhist community locally/more broadly; look for reasons for its establishment; pick two ‘types’ of Buddhism for contrast/comparison.

Is Buddhism a collection of traditions with little in common (AO2)? Note if you start with a clear ‘Yes’ or No’ answer you must also show what counter arguments there are to you view and why you have rejected them.

Why are there different views within Buddhism both to other forms of Buddhism and to other faiths?

Buddhist attitudes to other faiths – How may edict 12 of Ashoka influence these?

Does Buddhism have a positive attitude to religious pluralism?

Can Buddhism tolerate intolerance?



Harvey P, An introduction to Buddhism, teachings, history and practice, second edition, Cambridge University Press, 2013, pg 100–102, 233

Translation of edict 12

Dharma data: tolerance

Dalai Lama quotes about tolerance

dalailama.com

The Diplomat: Buddhist ‘nationalism’ in Sri Lanka



Buddhism and freedom of speech



Dostları ilə paylaş:


Verilənlər bazası müəlliflik hüququ ilə müdafiə olunur ©genderi.org 2019
rəhbərliyinə müraciət

    Ana səhifə