IJAPS, Vol. 13, No. 2, 73–91, 2017
© Penerbit Universiti Sains Malaysia, 2017. This work is licensed under the terms of the Creative
Commons Attribution (CC BY)(http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/).
"WE ARE THE WORLD ITSELF": THE
CONSTRUCTION OF "GOOD" CITIZENSHIP AND
DEVIATIONS FROM IT IN ERGO PROXY
Arnab Dasgupta
*
Centre for East Asian Studies, School of International Studies,
Jawaharlal Nehru University, New Delhi, 110067, India
email: arnabdasgupta2789@gmail.com
Published online: 15 July 2017
To cite this article: Dasgupta, A. 2017. "We are the world itself": The construction of
good citizenship and deviations from it in Ergo Proxy. International Journal of Asia
Pacific Studies 13 (2): 73–91, https://doi.org/10.21315/ijaps2017.13.2.4
To link to this article: https://doi.org/10.21315/ijaps2017.13.2.4
AbSTRACT
Anime is the dominant medium of pop-culture expression in modern Japan, lending
itself readily to genres such as romance and comedy, as well as advanced concepts
of social and political discourse. At the same time, the rise of modern anime,
especially science fiction anime coincided with the coming to the forefront of the
issue of immigration. This article attempts to understand how the two phenomena
may be intertwined in the dialectical process of analysing and re-analysing national
identity and belonging, through a critical interpretation of the anime series Ergo
Proxy, released in 2006. The ideas outlined below are relevant both to critical
discourse studies and for prospective solutions in the field of immigration policy.
With Japan's economy going into a tailspin due to the explosion of the housing
bubble in the 1990s, coupled with the detrimental effects of negative population
growth, more and more industries found themselves reliant on immigrant labour
for their survival, even as national political winds blew decisively against opening
the country to immigrants, due to unforeseen effects on "the Japanese way of life."
As Japan entered the second decade of its persistent recessionary state, and the
government remained impassive to calls issued from several quarters of society to
liberalise immigration policy, even though many of these workers were urgently
required in such important sectors as construction and healthcare, clinging instead
to outdated racist notions of "pure Japaneseness," a trickle of foreign workers
continued to enter Japan, becoming subject to abuse and human rights violations as
their existence continues to be systematically erased. The cultural intelligentsia of
IJAPS, Vol. 13, No. 2, 73–91, 2017
We are the World Itself
74
Japan did not long remain unaware of this fact, however, and has remained active in
depicting the plight of immigrants in various genres of creative production.
Keywords: Anime, cultural studies, Ergo Proxy, immigration, Japan
INTRODUCTION
Immigration is an urgent issue in Japan. Since the 1980s, a trickle of foreign
workers has been entering the country on a variety of visa categories, both
legal and illegal, taking advantage of Japan's "internationalisation" (kokusaika)
boom. These immigrants joined pre-existing populations of Korean and Chinese
citizens, who had been living in Japan since before the war and had traumatic
stories of their own to tell, stories of forced labour relocation, oppression and
cultural assimilation. Newer immigrants, though technically coming under the
category of economic labour, protected by international norms encapsulated
in Japan's ratification of United Nations instruments relating to human rights,
cultural protections and economic security, were in fact merely the newest
addition to a long trail of immigrants and refugees who had entered Japan in
the hopes of a safe haven to live and work, only to find themselves stuck in a
nation that did not want them, did not know what to do with them and could
not make heads or tails of their rights. In the face of this institutionalised
disregard, immigrants, displaying their typical ingenuity, managed to survive,
carving out small niches for themselves in spaces the government and the
native population could not control.
Over time, as Japan's demographic bomb exploded, leading to an
implosion of the social balance due to historically low birth rates and
unexpectedly high life expectancies, and the economy went into a tailspin
after the housing market collapsed on the back of excessive speculation, the
country became the first developed member of advanced nations to reach a
post-industrial, post-capitalist stage of limbo, where neither agriculture nor
manufacturing was sustaining national lifestyles, and the services sector
remained underdeveloped—and more importantly, helplessly parochial, as
cultural norms handicapped its viability as a regional and global services
powerhouse fully integrated into the global economy. Aggravating this
scenario was a profound negativity towards the processes of evolution and
change, resulting in a long-lasting economic depression that affected nearly
every sector of the industry, along with all of society. Rigidity in attitudes
toward modernisation and liberalisation, originating in the boom years of the
1960s and 1970s, became a crutch hobbling industries in the secondary and
IJAPS, Vol. 13, No. 2, 73–91, 2017
Arnab Dasgupta
75
tertiary sector, crippling the speed of recovery by deadlocking nearly every
measure institutional authorities could take to do so.
Nowhere was this more evident than in the dual structure of the Japanese
domestic manufacturing economy, which rapidly lost its raison d'etre and
subsided into inefficiency and high turnover, which was the niche filled by
immigrants. At the same time, the government remained so enamoured of
its own doctrine of cultural homogeneity leading to global supremacy that
it failed to appreciate the need for immigrants where they could count and
erected instead strong barriers against immigrants of nearly all stripes, seeing
in them an existential threat to some notional Japanese "uniqueness" instead
of an opportunity to achieve a more nuanced, richer conception of "being
Japanese." In effect, the Japanese state and the people who support it behaved
(and continue to behave) culturally in response to a phenomenon that is
political/economic in nature.
Within this general mainstream of rejection of immigrants, there are
voices which stand out in their positive depiction of these same immigrants.
There are many who embrace the cultural openness immigrants bring to local
neighbourhoods and wider urban societies, the splash of colour they bring
to an otherwise monocultural sphere of existence. Of these some have been
artists, who have used their art, their power to tell stories through paint, colour,
form and word to introduce their fellow-citizens to immigrants and the lives
they live, away from the public glare, many silently toiling away at their jobs,
building things that consumers in Japan and all around the world enjoy. These
expressions of sympathy, of co-existence, no doubt attract often diametrically
opposite views, but undeniably continue to be powerful vehicles for the
thinking about, and making sense of, the other that is an intrinsic function of
every art form.
Anime as a genre of popular art is not an exception, and has been
profoundly impacted by debates on immigration and citizenship issues. More
importantly, it has provided a two-dimensional sounding board on which
alternative visions of past, present and future Japan are shown, analysed and
constructed. Science fiction, dealing with the future, lends itself particularly
well to the medium of anime, since its stylistic and technological dimensions
can be most freely expressed in the unrealistic atmosphere of anime. But
whereas hard science fiction, dealing with matters of a technological and
scientific nature, excel particularly well there, soft science fiction dealing with
the socio-political impacts of technological advancements is also a well-suited
genre that anime has exploited particularly well. One example of a synthesis
of both genres is the science fiction anime series Ergo Proxy (2006), which
will be dealt with in the following lines.
IJAPS, Vol. 13, No. 2, 73–91, 2017
We are the World Itself
76
ENTERING A CRITICAL DYSTOPIA
Ergo Proxy belongs to the wider genre of cultural production in literature
and film that is known as the critical dystopia, which draws breath from the
long-hallowed traditions of dystopian literature. Originating in the late 19th
century, dystopian literature dealt overtly with what Murphy calls a "negative
utopia," the absolute opposite of the utopian trope employed by Defoe and
Verne (Murphy 2011: 473). In dystopian tales, the focus was often on the
exploration—and subversion of—the earnest desire of societies to achieve
perfection, and it was made clear at the outset that though the spatio-temporal
location of the dystopian society may be far away, it is the inevitable product
of a set of choices made by today's leaders and the societies they represent.
Dystopia thus proved to be a fertile medium to criticise contemporary politics
through an allegorical lens that remained sufficiently removed from the
circumstances so as to avoid government censorship.
This is not to say, however, that dystopian literature was meant to snuff
out hope. It was merely meant as a warning, a lighthouse warning those who
steered the ship of the state to stay away from rocky shoals. In this it was
different from the works of anti-utopia, which set out with the explicit objective
of "critiqu[ing] and nullify[ing] utopian hope" (Murphy 2011). Works such as
Yevgeny Zamyatin's We (1924), Huxley's Brave New World (1932) and Orwell's
masterpiece 1984 (1949) were all aimed at specific audiences, warning them
to desist from the alternative of their actions, especially if those resulted in
the formation of totalitarian states with fixed ideologies. It is no surprise that
most of these works emerged from the period immediately after World War
II, because the ideological conflict between the superpowers, each espousing
world-spanning ideologies, proved particularly fruitful for the proliferation of
cautionary tales involving one conceit or the other.
In the 1960s and 1970s, however, side by side with the anti-war
counter-culture movement, there arose a reactionary wave of oppositional (or
critical) utopia (Bacciolini and Moylan 2003a: 2). Taking inspiration from
the burgeoning ecological and feminist movements, authors such Ursula K.
Le Guin, Marge Piercy and Samuel R. Delany brought fresh perspectives to
bear on the science fiction genre, eschewing dystopian themes in favour of
more optimistic scenarios, where idyllic realms emerged from global war and
female members of the human race flourished atop the bones of their male
counterparts. No longer was utopia as unblemished as in the earlier days of
Butler and Defoe, but neither was it the grim totalitarian future envisaged by
Wells and Orwell.
IJAPS, Vol. 13, No. 2, 73–91, 2017
Arnab Dasgupta
77
This period was not to last, because the reheating of tensions between
the USA and the USSR, coupled with growing fears of Mutually Assured
Destruction (MAD) meant that the political again intruded on the creative, this
time in the form of a revival of dystopian literature in the 1980s (Bacciolini
and Moylan 2003a: 3). A new generation of authors emerged, who dealt with
new themes of societal collapse and totalitarian consolidation, taking as their
point of departure not the conventional tropes of war and peace, but rather
technological over-advancement and environmental crises. The former was
the preserve of the cyberpunk genre, which blended high technology with
classical themes of paranoia and deceit, both as state policy and individual
relations. The latter grew out of the works of authors such as Margaret Atwood,
whose The Handmaid's Tale (1985), though not a work of science fiction
per se, borrowed heavily from dystopian themes. It was also at this time that
1984 was finally filmed, bringing the horrors of totalitarian Oceania to theatre
screens all over the world.
Out of this dialectical contest between critical utopia and classical
dystopia emerged the synthesis: critical dystopia, a product of the 1990s. From
its very inception, critical dystopian texts set out to "negate the 1980s negation
of the critical utopian moment and thus make room for a new expression of
the utopian imagination" (Bacciolini and Moylan 2003a: 7). In effect, critical
dystopia was the true antithesis of critical utopia of the 1970s, because it in
effect reclaimed the same territory as the site for its contestation with the
latter. Works by Octavia E. Butler and Pat Cadigan were meant as warnings,
as rumblings of an oncoming storm that could destroy humanity as presently
constituted; in this they belonged properly to the classical dystopian genre.
Where they differed was in the "retriev[al] [of] the progressive possibilities
inherent in dystopian narrative" by "allow[ing] both readers and protagonists
to hope by resisting closure" (Bacciolini and Moylan 2003a: 7–8). Critical
dystopian texts were, therefore, stuck in an "impure" limbo between utopia
and dystopia, because they blended them both in an attempt to show that
hegemonies were not ossified monoliths but rather systems of oppression
shot through with holes that could be exploited by determined individuals to
achieve far-reaching change (Donawerth, in Bacciolini and Moylan 2003a).
The predominant trope of the critical dystopia thus became the depiction of
how an initially totalitarian or anarchic future could be converted into more
palatable alternatives by acts of active and passive resistance, especially by
members of oppressed underclasses who are denied their agency and voice by
a systematic campaign of dehumanisation.
IJAPS, Vol. 13, No. 2, 73–91, 2017
We are the World Itself
78
Given the historical period of the present, the urgency of artistic works
dealing with the gradual loss of humanity, of its values and its foundations, in
the hasty pursuit of instant technological gratification and the recrudescence
of human identities into isolated essentials, becomes unimpeachably relevant.
That critical dystopia remains relevant, and popular, in modern popular culture
can be seen from the ubiquity of the genre since its founding, with authors
adapting its tenets to effective use across ideologies (such as the eco-feminism
of Charnas's Holdfast series (Cavalcanti, in Bacciolini and Moylan 2003a)) as
well as media (comics, films, plays, etc.). What is more, critical dystopia now
commands a global reach and relevance, as seminal works of visual media
such as Katsuhiro Ōtomo's Akira (1988) and Hayao Miyazaki's Nausicaa of
the Valley of the Wind (1984) reveal. The subject of this article, Murase and
Satō's Ergo Proxy, is also of a piece with this genre, and the following lines
will explore how this anime partakes of generic tropes to voice the voiceless
(in this case, immigrants).
ERGO PROXY
AS A CRITICAL DYSTOPIA: AN EXPLORATION
Ergo Proxy (Murase 2006) is a Japanese cyberpunk science fiction anime
spanning 25 episodes which aired in Japan between February and July 2006
in Japan. Directed by Shukō Murase, the series was based on a manga written
by Yumiko Harao, published serially in Monthly Sunday-GX from the 18
February 2006 issue. Harao's manga was adapted for the screen by Dai Satō
and a team of other screenwriters working on individual episodes. Under
the direction of Murase, several episodes were directed by other directors,
including Akira Yoshimura (Episode 9), Satoshi Toba (5 episodes) and Tatsuya
Igarashi (Episodes 3, 13, 20). Music for the series was provided by Yoshihiro
Ike, while the distinctive art was handled by Naoyuki Onda (character design),
Takashi Aoi and Kazuhiro Yamada (director of photography). The principal
characters were voiced by Koji Yusa (Vincent Law), Rie Saitō (Re-l Mayer),
Hikaru Hanada (Raul Creed) and Akiko Yajima (Pino). The broadcaster of the
series is the WOWOW channel, while production was done by a consortium of
anime studios including Geneon Entertainment Inc., Manglobe (which owns
the rights to the manga), Rondo Robe and WOWOW (Anime News Network
n.d.).
After its release in Japan, the anime DVD was subsequently dubbed into
other languages for international broadcast and sales. In the English-speaking
world, broadcasting was handled by Animax (South Africa), FUNimation
IJAPS, Vol. 13, No. 2, 73–91, 2017
Arnab Dasgupta
79
Entertainment, Fuse TV and G4TechTV Canada. FUNimation also handled
distribution along with Madman Entertainment (Australia and New Zealand),
MVM (UK) and Universal Sony Home Pictures. The anime was also dubbed
into French (broadcasters Game one and Gong; distributor Dybex), Spanish
(broadcasters Animax Spain, Buzz Channel and LAPTV; distributor Alter
Films), Italian (broadcaster Rai 4; distributor Panini Film Italia), German
(broadcaster Animax Germany; distributors Nipponart and SP Vision), Russian
(distributor MC Entertainment) and Polish (broadcaster Canal+; distributor
Vision Film Distribution Sp. Z.o.o.) (Anime News Network n.d.).
Ergo Proxy has received great support and critical acclaim since its
release. Its IMDb entry rates it 8.1 out of 10 (IMDb n.d.), while TV.com rates
it higher, at 8.7 out of 10 (Deershadow n.d.). Amazon.com users have rated it
4.5 out of 5, with 67 percent voting for 5 stars. The series was also positively
received by bloggers; T.H.E.M. Anime Reviews (themanime.org) rates it 4 out
of 5, comparing it to Serial Experiments Lain and Ghost in the Shell in terms
of content, while faulting the anime for its slow pace and inconsistencies in
design (T.H.E.M. Anime Reviews n.d.). Another blog, The Nihon Review
(nihonreview.com) rates it 7 out of 10, appreciating the "hauntingly beautiful
and enigmatic" music, strong characterisations and "weighty" philosophical
content, while critiquing its ending (AC n.d.). Anime News Network
(animenewsnetwork.com) gives Ergo Proxy an overall grade of B+, calling it
"a fine addition to the genre," "a top-shelf title that any high-minded sci-fi fan
[…] will probably enjoy" (Santos 2012).
The present study will approach Ergo Proxy from a critical studies
perspective, which is to say it will consider the series not as a work of art but
as a product conveying the ideas, opinions and policy stands of the creators,
as well as accepting in an implicit manner the receptivity of the audience as
indirect endorsement of its message. The focus of the study will be on the
portrayals of the varied facets of citizenship depicted by the principal characters
of the series. The following sections will deal with the varied sites, ideologies
and characters in the series which provide insights into understanding the
underlying message of the creators. The relevant points in the storyline will be
critically interpreted as a semiotic text with real-world application.
ROMDEAU: THE LAST ARK
The ark city of Romdeau is the centrepiece of the series, where most of
the principal characters reside and begin their journeys. It is also the place
IJAPS, Vol. 13, No. 2, 73–91, 2017
We are the World Itself
80
where the story meets its denouement, with the promise of a brave new world
built atop its destroyed ruins. Consider its geographical features: Romdeau
is a hermeneutically-sealed ark city, self-sufficient into itself and containing
within itself a citizenry which goes about its daily life unperturbed by external
interference. This citizenry is shown to be affluent, self-satisfied and suitably
compliant toward the ultimate sources of authority resident in the Regent,
Donov Mayer, and his artificial intelligence (AI) shadow cabinet (each named
after a prominent 20th century philosopher, Kristeva and Kierkegaard being
prominent examples). Around the "dome" of Romdeau stretches a wasteland
which is viewed by those within as terra nullius, the site of dragons and
unimaginable tragedies. Also important is the fact that this self-same citizenry
is hopelessly dependent on robotic AutoReivs who pander to their every whim,
and remains blissfully unaware of the reality of its existence, revealed only
to the principal characters by the end of the story: namely, that the citizens
of Romdeau are in fact endlessly-repetitive clones of the original human
population, assembly-line echoes of an original humanity which died in the
"calamity" of nuclear holocaust an indeterminate time before the events of the
story. What is more, their saviour, the entity that gave them life and secured
their livelihood is the inhuman Proxy, servant of God the Creator, sent down
from the heavens to protect humanity from assured destruction. This god-like
being, however, is so universally reviled and misunderstood that it chooses
to leave its creations and emigrate to another domed city. Upon its return, as
Vincent Law, this immigrant as Father is not only unrecognised; he is hunted
by the security apparatus and ultimately ejected. In Vincent's own words, he
"fails to become a good citizen" (Episode 1).
To the viewer concerned with the deconstruction of its symbolic
significance, Romdeau can be effectively said to stand for the creators'
conception of Japan. Isolated from the Asian mainland, to the point that political
regimes in the past could choose what social, political and cultural features to
integrate into the national mainstream, Japan has always considered itself to
be separate from and (overtly during the historical periods between 1603 and
1853 and 1910 to 1945) superior to its distant neighbours on the mainland.
Nowadays, despite several warning signs issued by local and international
commentators, politicians and academics about the absolute urgency of
accepting immigration into Japan in quantities ranging from thousands to the
hundreds of thousands, mainstream media outlets, internet forums and public
discussion continue to equate the immigrant not with a valuable economic
entity, source of social capital or a "citizen-in-waiting" (to borrow the title of a
book by Hiroshi Motomura on immigration and citizenship law) but as a threat
IJAPS, Vol. 13, No. 2, 73–91, 2017
Arnab Dasgupta
81
to the social fabric of Japan's "unique" system, whose incorporation would
reduce something "essential" in the identity of "Japaneseness." The Japanese
government continues to officially suppress immigration and citizenship for
foreign populations, while proposals to "robotise" and "mechanise" such
sectors as office work and care for the elderly are seriously investigated.
Even those foreigners who manage to surpass Japan's tough immigration
requirements, either legally or illegally, are treated socially as perpetually
foreign. Like the refugees of Romdeau, they are expected at all times to perform
their foreignness in public in ways that may in fact be a source of considerable
confusion to the younger generation which may have acclimatised itself to its
destination country's mores. The native population remains apathetic at best,
and hostile at worst, giving rise to several public incidents of harassment and
assault with a racial bent. Meanwhile, the granting of the (elusive) citizenship
status is hedged about by vague requirements of "adaptability to the Japanese
way of life," whose parameters are set in an ad hoc way and applied on a
case-by-case basis, which means there is no standardised set of milestones the
future citizen-immigrant can aim to achieve in order to receive citizenship.
Romdeau's system is essentially the fictional counterpart of this system, which
the creators of Ergo Proxy set up in the series, only to eventually upend it
by introducing the placid members of their fictional collective to the truth of
their origin as the progeny of an artificial decision by an immigrant founder to
settle and raise his community there. The knowledge of this shared origin as
ancient immigrants tears the fragile fabric of the domed city apart, as Romdeau
collapses under the weight of its failure to survive as a viable community of
human beings rising out of nuclear devastation. It takes the return (for the
third time) of the original immigrant founder, Vincent Law/Ergo Proxy, for
hope of an eventual revitalisation to emerge.
VINCENT LAW: THE IMMIGRANT AS FOUNDER
Vincent Law is the male protagonist of the series, the subject and agent of
the whole narrative, whose journey of rediscovery of himself, both as the
Othered Proxy of the title as well as his role as the founder of the ark of
Romdeau, saviour of the human race, forms the chief vehicle for conveying
its principal ideas. Vincent is the subject through which the series interrogates
and problematises the existing narratives revolving around immigration,
citizenship and the quest for a common origin prevalent throughout the elite in
Romdeau, which, as has already been shown, stands as a metonym for Japan.
IJAPS, Vol. 13, No. 2, 73–91, 2017
We are the World Itself
82
At the beginning of the series, the viewer sees Vincent working in
a basement as part of a team that captures and repairs AutoReivs infected
with a virus which gives them a conscience. He is called in by Re-l Mayer,
who represents the security architecture of the state, to shed some light on a
recent spate of events which involve him being seen in close proximity to the
mysterious beings known as Proxies. Visibly nervous, he professes himself
confused and attempts to show himself an honest worker who has kept his head
down and tried his best to obey the dictates of the government of Romdeau,
in order to finally attain the mantle of being a "good citizen" and be able to
move up in life. As the investigation into Vincent's role deepens throughout
the episode, both Re-l and Vincent realise that he is in reality something else
altogether. His ensuing pursuit by members of the security architecture, led
by Re-l, leads Vincent to make a fateful decision and voluntarily exile himself
from Romdeau by throwing himself out the airlock of the domed city. The entire
time, he exists in shadow, hovering about in the pipes and underground tunnels
of the city, serving the "good citizens" above while remaining uncomplaining,
invisible.
In later episodes, as Vincent picks himself back up and commences
a journey back towards the domed city of Mosk from which he believes
himself to have emerged originally, he encounters people and circumstances
(sometimes bordering on the hallucinatory) which make him aware of his true
self. In a pivotal episode (episode 9), he meets another Proxy, the Proxy of
Sunlight, who fights him initially, but upon recognising him, reveals to him
the truth: that he is a Proxy, a being created by unknown powers, each given
charge over a "flock" of humans to save and restore. This shocking revelation
unsettles Vincent's identity and self at first; for a moment he sees himself
clearly as both the monstrous Proxy and the harmless, diligent Vincent. In
ensuing episodes, initially alone then joined by Re-l, Vincent successfully
pieces together the remaining shards of his past, to reconstruct an identity of
his own. In the process, he comes to see what he is in relation to the city of
Romdeau and learns that his present exile is the third of his attempts to liberate
himself of his creation.
In the final third of the series, as Vincent and Re-l return to Romdeau to
save it from destruction, Vincent is finally revealed by the elites of Romdeau
as the Founder of the city who eventually grew disgusted with it and decided
to leave. Yet for emotional reasons he continued to return to the city as a
lowly immigrant, only being rejected by a hostile population which failed
to recognise its own progenitor. Even in Mosk, where Vincent/Ergo Proxy
takes refuge, the population of Romdeau wages a war to recover him, but
IJAPS, Vol. 13, No. 2, 73–91, 2017
Arnab Dasgupta
83
only to contain him, to imprison him so that he may continue to be "useful"
to the city as the producer of more human beings through the cloning process.
Above all there exists the important truth that the same elites, particularly the
Regent, Re-l's "grandfather" Donov Mayer, knew of their immigrant origin
and purposefully effaced this part of their history in order to retain people's
faith in the system of political control built up around them. The immigrant
Founder of the state is thus himself made subject to its mechanisms of control
and regulation.
Vincent in Romdeau is thus the Othered part of the city's history, whose
role in the origin of its people is conveniently removed without trace by the
state in order to cement its control over their minds and champion an ideology
which in the series comes eerily close to emulating the exhortations of the
Nihonjinron genre of Japanese literature, which harps on the "uniqueness" of
Japanese culture as the foundationary principle of its success in the economic
sphere. The immigrant, though he is effectively repeating the journey made by
the ancestors of the Japanese/Romdeauites, is only ever useful in the underclass
of economic production, where he/she is useful in a limited sense, as long
as he/she remains dispensable and invisible to the citizenry. By placing this
immigrant (in this case Vincent Law) in a fixed position legally, by constraining
him within the boundaries of "manageable" structures (prison, the workshop,
outside the physical borders of the territory of the state) and by denying him/
her the voice and agency to claim and reconstitute him/herself as a valuable
unit of the national fabric, an important member of the national fraternity,
and as a human being with rights and values, the state of Romdeau/Japan
thus effectively denies its origins in prehistoric immigration patterns in favour
of a limited, conservative ethno-racial conception of itself as a monoethnic,
monolingual nation-state continuing in a pure form from the mists of history
to the present day.
RE-L MAYER: THE NATIVE WHO WENT IMMIGRANT
If Vincent Law is the Othered origin of Romdeau, Re-l Mayer, security agent,
adopted granddaughter of the Regent and a former member of the political
elite who turns on her own people for the truth, is the hopeful vehicle for
the future. As envisioned by the creators of Ergo Proxy, Re-l, the initially
prickly unfeminine officer, becomes by the end a feminised "super-female,"
who essays a dual role as both the amanuensis of Vincent's journey and the
potential foundress of a new human society after the destruction of Romdeau,
IJAPS, Vol. 13, No. 2, 73–91, 2017
We are the World Itself
84
in a procreative dyad with the Othered immigrant Vincent Law. In sum, Re-l
is the native who accepts the immigrant into her body, both physically and
symbolically as a human being in the shared confraternity of human beings.
In the sense considered above, Re-l's femininity is important to the
storytellers. The existence of a female protagonist, through whose eyes the
viewer experiences the torment of Vincent/Ergo Proxy, serves to impart an
affective legitimacy to Vincent's reclaiming of his split personality. At the
same time, Re-l's presence, particularly her personal emotional development,
attempts to instil faith in the change that Vincent promises would come in the
final episode; Re-l's being at his side will ensure a more even-handed, fairer
world where the artificiality of Romdeau's technology-aided reproduction
would be replaced by a "natural" order of sexually generated humanity
which would (purportedly) claim for itself a "pure" status free of distinctions
between imimmigrants and natives. Thus Re-l Mayer reifies the conception of
the nation/collective/human race as products of a "universal mother" in whose
body the potential for change may gestate.
In the initial half of the series, Re-l is shown as a loyal and intelligent
security officer whose keen eye and critical faculties enable her to see the
problem of Romdeau's growing AutoReiv problem more clearly than all others.
When Ergo Proxy's existence is revealed to her in a shocking home invasion
at the end of the first episode, Re-l, instead of giving in to human feelings
of antipathy and trauma, begins to analyse the Proxy's seeming interest in
her, honestly confessing to the audience that that interest is fully reciprocated.
Later on, when her duty forces her to chase down Vincent, she attempts to
arrest him with tact, resisting to the very end the use of force. After the truth
of Vincent's identity and the source of Romdeau's citizens is revealed to her by
Daedalus in a later episode, she resolves to go out into the wilderness outside
Romdeau to look for Vincent, to interrogate him and (if necessary) kill him.
However, when she catches up to him, Vincent saves her life instead. This
marks the point where Re-l begins her journey of discovery, one potentially
challenging her own long-held beliefs and the threat potential Vincent seems
to pose.
Over time, as their journey leads to deeper and more desolate places,
the bond between Re-l and Vincent metamorphoses from a wary distrust
into a lasting companionship, emblematised by an episode where they are
stranded in a deserted place with no wind to propel their wind-driven ship.
By the final episodes, Re-l becomes the first person to accept the broken
halves of Vincent's identity, propelling him to return to Romdeau to save it
instead of destroying it. She becomes his moral centre, arming him for a final
IJAPS, Vol. 13, No. 2, 73–91, 2017
Arnab Dasgupta
85
confrontation with his own alternate self, which advocates the final destruction
of Romdeau by the Proxy's hands. After the climactic battle is done, Vincent,
the immigrant returned to the land of his founding, stands atop the ruins of his
creation; his sight of Re-l returning to him in their ship forms the background
to his vow to rebuild a new society again, thus (indirectly) investing Re-l
with regenerative capacities not only in a physical sense, but also as a moral
compass, a role that presents direct comparisons with Meiji era exhortations
to create "good wives, wise mothers" (ryōsai kenbo) as the source of a new
generation of loyal, disciplined and intelligent citizens who would lead Japan
into modernity.
It cannot be guessed as to whether the anime producers wanted at this
point to show a return to the essential core of culture as imperative to national
rejuvenation, or to indicate a radically progressive vision of the role of women
to subvert andthrough their roles as wives and mothers (of immigrant men
and their children)challenge the exclusionary principles of Japan's almost-
xenophobic immigration policy, but Re-l's character trajectory may be said
to stand most simplistically to signify the advantages of what in the field
of immigration studies is called "contact theory," which argues that contact
with immigrants has a direct positive relation with attitudes towards them
in personal life; essentially, the more natives see immigrants navigating the
same environmental challenges they do, the more they come to see the latter
as fellow-travellers, not as threats (Green and Kadoya 2015). Re-l can thus
be read as a metonym for Japanese people at large, who if only they could
see immigrants in their daily lives and emotional turmoil, would realise the
common humanity of both groups and come to give the latter a more basic role
in the construction of Japanese-ness in an era of rapid aging and globalised
migration.
RAUL CREED: THE (PERSONAL) SECURITY ESTAbLISHMENT
If Re-l Mayer represents the benign face of Romdeau's security establishment,
her boss Raul Creed represents its xenophobic mainstream. Through his
character, the creators of Ergo Proxy attempt to delineate a sort of "banal
evil" (Arendt 2006) as envisioned by Hannah Arendt, a functionary who loses
sight of the humanity of the immigrants under his supervision in favour of
a functional, and then an overtly emotional reaction against one immigrant
in particular, i.e., Vincent Law. The trajectory of his character is emblematic
of the security establishment he represents, an establishment which sees
IJAPS, Vol. 13, No. 2, 73–91, 2017
We are the World Itself
86
immigrants not in terms of their intrinsic human value but as potential threats
and subversive agents, to the point that it begins to drive a xenophobic knee-
jerk counter-reaction toward immigration at large irrespectively of its economic
and demographic benefits. This hyperactive domination of immigration
policymaking by the security establishment leads to the irrelevance of
Romdeau/Japan at first, and eventually to its summary destruction in the final
episode of the series.
When the audience first encounters Creed, he comes across as a coldly
efficient functionary with a mandate to maintain surveillance on all citizens of
Romdeau for signs of "deviance." This mandate includes identifying defective
AutoReivs and "fixing" (i.e., destroying) them. In the first episode, though, the
battle of the Proxies in the central shopping district causes a defining break in
Creed's pathology as his wife and child are caught in the crossfire and killed.
Throughout the ensuing series, Creed's blinding desire for revenge against the
Proxies causes him to fall further and further into doubt regarding the essential
purpose of his and others' lives. This doubt is exacerbated by Daedalus, who
shows him the "truth" of Romdeau's artificial population growth. Armed
with the knowledge of life's essential meaninglessness, Creed eventually
devotes all the resources at his disposal to hunt down Vincent Law, whom
he sees haunting him in several telling hallucinatory sequences. The Regent's
removal of his powers and authority only makes him more determined, and
he eventually becomes the agent of the system's demise when he triggers the
Legacy, one last nuclear missile left over from pre-apocalyptic times, over
Romdeau, causing its protective dome to collapse and its civilisation to come
to an end. When he receives news of Vincent/Ergo Proxy's return, he goes
to the Regent's chamber and fires bullets containing life-threatening FP cells
at his hated enemy, only to realise that the enemy is more resourceful and
more powerful than him. After his "nominal" revenge is taken, Creed wanders
aimlessly through the runs of Romdeau until his accidental death.
The character of Raul Creed offers to the student of citizenship and
immigration a valuable example of the security establishment of "anti-
immigration" countries such as Japan and the functionaries who serve as its
gatekeepers. His cold attitude towards the immigrants who serve as Romdeau's
underclass, his inveterate hatred toward Vincent Law and his eventual decision
to prefer the destruction of his homeland to his fellow citizens learning the truth
about their origins are all mirrored to some extent in the attitudes and policy
behaviours of immigration bureaucrats in real-life Japan, who along with the
ministers above them, stoke the public's nativist attitudes even at the cost of
national decrepitude (and eventual decline). Recent initiatives by the Japanese
IJAPS, Vol. 13, No. 2, 73–91, 2017
Arnab Dasgupta
87
government, such as automation of certain tasks as well as incorporating women
into the workforce through the so-called "womenomics," are indicative of this
fatalist attitude towards replenishment of national populations by immigration,
which accentuates perceived security concerns and difficulties of integration
as obstacles to immigration while ignoring the historical inevitability of
immigration, its benefits and complexities. The national discourse is thus posed
as a straightforward nation vs. outsiders (the literal meaning of gaijin) debate,
instead of allowing pro- and anti-migrant interests to dispute immigrants'
viability in terms of their respective standpoints.
The Japanese government's negative attitudes towards immigrants
have a historical dimension as well. Opponents of immigration within the
government (of which the security establishment is one) often argue their
opposition by drawing comparisons with the United States, which is a country
of immigrants and thus the opposite of Japan. This argument, drawing from
years of Nihonjinron discourse and official government support to the concept
of tan'itsu minzoku kokka (literally translated as racially homogeneous nation),
has been the mainstay of official circles since Nakasone Yasuhiro proclaimed
in a public speech his nation's superiority over the United States because of the
latter's lax immigration policies allowing blacks, Puerto Ricans and other poor
immigrants to stay and work there (Page 1986). However, as detailed historical
data proves, Japan itself has been home to populations from Asia, Polynesian
islanders and Australasian aborigines, who combined prior to recorded history
to form the much-vaunted Yamato race that Japanese political functionaries
tout today as a "pure" race. Even in recorded history, several thousands of
Koreans and Chinese were captured and brought to Japan for their skills; these
craftspeople were no doubt incorporated into the Japanese population, since
their descendants are now unidentifiable as members of that special group.
Seen from the contexts noted above, Creed's behaviour seems to
be more explainable. Like the real bureaucrats on whom he seems to be
modelled, he not only harbours an atavistic hatred for immigrants but also
resents the fact of their value to society. As such his hatred for Vincent Law
can be interpreted as having two reasons: by failing to become an anonymous,
compliant Fellow Citizen, in effect by refusing to sublimate his individuality
to the corporate group of the state, Vincent Law has shown himself to be a
typical outsider/foreigner/immigrant, a threat to the security of the nation. Not
only that, Vincent has been revealed to be the Proxy, founder of Romdeau,
father of all its citizens and emissary of the past, making his presence a threat
to the official shibboleths of the state, which declaims that Romdeau/Japan is
a self-contained population free of intermixing with "foreign" races. From this
IJAPS, Vol. 13, No. 2, 73–91, 2017
We are the World Itself
88
perspective it is no wonder that Creed's rebellion encompasses both Vincent
Law, the representative of the past, of the common origins of all humanity
after the apocalypse, and of Romdeau, Vincent's creation, which he sees as
the contaminated paradise. By striving to destroy both, Creed may in fact be
striving to achieve the perfect purity, an unsullied tabula rasa where tan'itsu
minzoku kokka may be established free of the taint of association with the
foreign "barbarian." His failure can thus be read as the failure of the state to
hold the gates, to argue against the inevitability of human immigration.
CONCLUSION
It is difficult to estimate how many unique viewers eventually watched Ergo
Proxy, because it was released as a DVD simultaneously with broadcast on
a satellite television channel, which is dependent on subscribers. A search of
interviews conducted with the creators has made amply clear that they were
influenced by the Christian doctrine of Manicheanism and sought to construct
a morality tale of dystopian proportions (see Scally, Drummond-Matthews
and Hairston 2009), but none of the interviews have made entirely clear
where the inspiration for the realistic depiction of issues of immigration and
citizenship came from or even whether they were intentional. A search of the
existing literature in academic circles also reveals nothing; most students of
immigration studies remain unaware of the critical potential Ergo Proxy (and a
handful of other series like it) holds for those specialising in emergent countries
of immigration, almost all of which are so-called monoethnic, monolingual
states without traditions of mass immigration in modern times (such as Italy,
Spain, Greece and Japan).
Ergo Proxy, and indeed other anime produced across studios in Japan,
nevertheless offers rich dividends for these students. Firstly, it problematises the
existing immigration policy espoused by the political apparatus in Japan, which
attempts to display a veneer of control even in the face of dire demographic
crises, relying on wishful thinking due to cultural sensitivities instead of taking
a dispassionate look at all the options available to the government. Romdeau's
destruction comes about because instead of confronting and internalising its
history, its citizens and elites wish to remain in denial about the source of
salvation that their refugee underclass represent and stress their purity instead.
In light of Romdeau's (fictional) experiences, the producers of Ergo Proxy
seem to be warning real-life Japanese audiences of the folly of clinging to
outdated concepts of racial purity when a real crisis is facing them.
IJAPS, Vol. 13, No. 2, 73–91, 2017
Arnab Dasgupta
89
Secondly, Ergo Proxy sends up a cautionary flare to the political elite
by threatening nothing less than irrelevance or (in the worst instance) the
destruction of the nation-state if changes to the immigration policy are not
made. The producers of the anime, by showing how Creed ends up enacting
the destruction of the stable polity of Romdeau because the boundary between
the personal and the political ceases to be relevant for him, are possibly
indicating that several real cases of official misconduct by several immigration
authorities and detention centre officers may just be the tip of the iceberg,
because they may indicate a sense of racial superiority that is at odds with
the sensitivity which Japanese politicians believe remains Japan's greatest
diplomatic weapon. As such, the anime it can be said argues for a humanitarian
approach towards immigrants, instead of the cycle of violence which Creed
unleashes by blaming Vincent Law for all the problems the former's society
faces.
Thirdly, Ergo Proxy unveils the potential that recent advances in social
psychology such as contact theory hold in changing public attitudes toward
immigrants. Throughout the series, the audience is able to see with their own
eyes how increasing contact with Vincent makes Re-l change her preconceived
attitudes and private fears about the alien in her society, leading her to ultimately
accept Vincent as her mate and equal. That this act of acceptance, mirrored in
the real world, would end the underground lives most immigrants to Japan still
live, and enable them to access their rights in a manner free of fear or favour
seems to be the primary contention of the creators of the anime.
Finally, and most importantly, however, Ergo Proxy attempts to
humanise the immigrant, not just by showing him as a silent, compliant victim
enmeshed in a system which needs him at the same time as it refuses to grant
him the needs of self-activation that is enjoyed by full citizens, but also as a
successor to the true past: a past of itinerant immigrants, ancestors of the same
citizens who came to an unexplored land to settle it. By making an impassioned
plea to respect the stranger as God (Yoshida 1981), to welcome the immigrant
as a future citizen instead of as a tool, to respect his/her power to make and
unmake the nation's common peace, prosperity and longevity, Ergo Proxy can
in this reading be said to be pushing the idea of a critical dystopia for Japan's
consideration, where the possibility of change exists and a better future is still
around the corner.
IJAPS, Vol. 13, No. 2, 73–91, 2017
We are the World Itself
90
NOTES
*
Arnab Dasgupta is an Indian citizen and resident in the national capital of Delhi. He is
currently engaged in the production of his PhD thesis on Japan's immigration policy
as it is perceived by the state as against civil society. He has Bachelors' and Masters'
degrees in the Japanese language from the School of Languages, Literature and Culture,
Jawaharlal Nehru University, New Delhi, India and has previously obtained an MPhil
from the institution he is currently affiliated to, where his topic was the evolution of
Japanese immigration policy from the period 2000–2012. He is a keen follower of
Japan in world news and opinion, and is a devotee of Japanese food, anime, manga,
music and films. He has been a recipient of numerous awards and scholarships awarded
by the Government of India as well as the Japan Foundation and private institutions.
His professional aim is to teach at a higher learning institution, and wants to do his part
in building a bridge between the nations of East and Southeast Asia and India.
REFERENCES
AC. n.d. Ergo Proxy. http://www.thenihonreview.com/anime/ergo-proxy/ (accessed 16
May 2016).
Anime News Network. n.d. Ergo Proxy (TV). http://www.animenewsnetwork.com/
encyclopedia/anime.php?id=5115 (accessed 17 May 2016).
Arendt, H. 2006. Eichmann in Jerusalem: A report on the banality of evil. London and New
York: Penguin.
Bacciolini, R. and Moylan, T. 2003a. Introduction: Dystopia and histories. In Dark horizons:
Science fiction and the dystopian imagination, ed. Bacciolini, R. and Moylan, T.
London and New York: Routledge.
. 2003b. Conclusion: Critical dystopia and possibilities. In Dark horizons:
Science fiction and the dystopian imagination, ed. Bacciolini, Raffaela and Moylan,
Tom. London and New York: Routledge.
Cavalcanti, I. 2003. The writing of utopia and the feminist critical dystopia: Suzy McKee
Charnas's Holdfast Series. In Dark horizons: Science fiction and the dystopian
imagination, ed. Bacciolini, R. and Moylan, T. London and New York: Routledge.
Deershadow. n.d. Ergo Proxy. http://www.tv.com/shows/ergo-proxy/ (accessed 17 May
2016).
Donawerth, J. 2003. Genre blending and the critical dystopia. In Dark horizons: Science
fiction and the dystopian imagination, ed. Bacciolini, R. and Moylan, T. London
and New York: Routledge.
Green, D. and Kadoya, Y. 2015. Contact and threat: Factors affecting views on increasing
immigration in Japan. Politics and Policy 43 (1): 59–93, https://doi.org/10.1111/
polp.12109.
IMDb. n.d. Ergo Proxy (TV Series 2006- ). http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0791205/ (accessed
17 May 2016).
Murase, S. 2006. Ergo Proxy. Tokyo: Manglobe.
IJAPS, Vol. 13, No. 2, 73–91, 2017
Arnab Dasgupta
91
Murphy, G. J. 2011. Dystopia. In The Routledge companion to science fiction, ed. Bould,
M. et al. Abingdon, Oxon and New York: Routledge.
Page, C. 1986. Nakasone puts foot in melting pot. Chicago Tribune, 28 September.
Santos, C. 2012. Ergo Proxy complete collection DVD – Review. http://www.
animenewsnetwork.com/review/ergo-proxy/dvd-complete-series-anime-classics
(accessed 16 May 2016).
Scally, D., Drummond-Matthews, A. and Hairston, M. 2009. Interview with Murase Shūkō
and Satō Dai. Mechademia 9: 329–334, https://doi.org/10.1353/mec.0.0064.
T.H.E.M Anime Reviews 4.0. 2006. Ergo Proxy. http://www.themanime.org/viewreview.
php?id=1377 (accessed 17 May 2016).
Yoshida, T. 1981. The stranger as God: The place of the outsider in Japanese folk religion.
Ethnology 20:2: 87–99, https://doi.org/10.2307/3773058.
Dostları ilə paylaş: |