20
Independent reading promotes active problem solving
and higher-order cognitive
processes. It is these processes which equip each student to read increasingly more
complex texts over time; “resulting in
better reading comprehension, writing style,
vocabulary, spelling and grammatical development”. “It is important to note that guided
reading is not round robin reading. When students are reading during the independent
reading stage, all children must have a copy of the text and individually read the whole
text or a meaningful segment of a text (e.g. a chapter). Students also have an important
role in guided reading as the teacher supports them to practise
and further explore
important reading strategies”
7
.
Peer observation of guided reading practice (for teachers)
Providing opportunities for teachers to learn about teaching practices, sharing of
evidence-based methods and finding out what is working and for whom, all contribute to
developing a culture that will make a difference to student outcomes (Hattie, 2009, pp.
241-242). When there has been dedicated and strategic
work by a Principal and the
leadership team to set learning goals and targeted focuses, teachers have clear direction
about what to expect and how to go about successfully implementing core teaching and
learning practices. One way to monitor the growth of teacher capacity and whether new
learning has become embedded is by setting up peer observations with colleagues. It is a
valuable tool to contribute to informed, whole-school approaches to teaching and
learning. The focus of the peer observation must be determined before the practice takes
place. This ensures all participants in the process are clear about the intention. Peer
observations will only be successful if they are viewed as a collegiate activity
based on
trust. According to Bryk and Schneider, high levels of “trust reduce the sense of
vulnerability that teachers experience as they take on new and uncertain tasks associated
7
West, Michael. (1937). “The Reading Approach and the New Method System.”
The
Modern Language Journal
. Available: http://www.jstor.org/stable/317672, accessed April 15, 2011.
21
with reform” and help ensure the feedback after an observation is valued (as cited in
Hattie, 2009, p. 241). To improve the practice of guided reading, peer observations can
be arranged across Year levels or within a Year level depending on the focus. A
framework for the observations is useful so that both parties know what it is that will be
observed. It is important that the observer note down what they see and hear the teacher
and the students say and do. Evidence must be tangible and not related to opinion, bias
or interpretation (Danielson, 2012).
Examples of evidence relating to the guided reading practice might be:
•
the words the teacher says (Today’s learning intention is to focus on making sure
our reading makes sense. If it doesn’t, we need to reread and problem solve the
tricky word)
•
the words the students say (My reading goal is to break up a word into smaller parts
when I don’t know it to help me decode)
•
the actions of the teacher (Taking anecdotal notes as
they listen to individual
students read)
•
what they can see the students doing (The group members all have their own copy
of the text and read individually).
Noting specific examples of engagement and practice and using a reflective tool allows
reviewers to provide feedback that is targeted to the evidence rather than the personality.
Finding time for face-to-face feedback is a vital stage in peer observation. Danielson
argues that “the conversations following an observation are the best opportunity to
engage teachers in thinking through how they can strengthen their practice”.