Chapter 7 - Exploring the social biographical patterns of Dutch mothers’ attitudes
171
of the interviews were made. In order to select the interviewees, four categories
of mothers were differentiated according to their employment patterns: mothers
who work 0 hours (referred to as stay-at-home mothers or full-time homemakers),
12 to 24 hours a week (mothers with a small part-time job), 25 to 35 hours
(mothers with a large part-time job) and 36 hours or more (full-time working
mothers).
As is well known, higher educational levels lead to higher levels of labour
participation, especially among mothers (Merens et al., 2011). Sufficient
education is then understood as a precondition for labour market participation.
For example, higher educated women work more, because their higher wage
allows them to pay for child-care facilities. They may also have been exposed
more to critical ideas and formed career-oriented networks (Cunningham et al.,
2005; Doorewaard et al., 2004, p.11). In 2009, 37 per cent
of Dutch higher-
educated mothers worked more than 35 hours per week, compared to only 18 per
cent of lower-educated mothers. 52 per cent of lower-educated mothers did not
participate in the labour market at all, as compared to 12 per cent of higher-
educated mothers (Central Bureau of Statistics, Statline, 2011). In each of the
four
employment categories, there were approximately equal numbers of lower-
(intermediate vocational level and lower) and higher- educated mothers (higher
vocational level and university).
For theoretical reasons, the sample of interviewed mothers was drawn largely
within one urban area, Amsterdam. In this way, differences in employment
behaviour and attitudes among respondents do not differ with respect to the
influence of structural and cultural factors that may diverge between urban and
rural areas, such as the availability
of childcare provisions, jobs and religiousness,
which could also affect potential differences in gender and work attitudes.
In order to achieve good correspondence between research questions and
sampling, a strategy of purposeful sampling had to be followed (Bryman, 2008,
p.458-459). To be able to fill all eight categories (four along employment patterns
and two along educational levels) of mothers within one area equally, the
respondents were found using the snowball method. The collection of material
ended when theoretical saturation was reached, and new interviewees did not
bring more diversity. Quite clearly this research method cannot produce a
statistically
representative sample, since it relies upon the social contacts between
individuals to trace additional contacts. The research method, however, does
permit revealing the reciprocal character between primary and secondary
socialization, and is able to highlight what mothers consider as being relevant
when describing their childhood and further social relational contexts.
Firstly, a small group of mothers in the social environment of the researcher,
the so-called weak ties (Granovetter, 1973), was approached, especially at a
primary school in Amsterdam (Old West Quarter). Subsequently, the other
respondents were approached on the advice of the first group of respondents.
Socialized Choices - Labour Market Behaviour of Dutch Mothers
172
Research group
The interviewed mothers were born between 1962 and 1980. Their average age
was 39.3 years. Seven interviewees (18 per cent) had a non-Dutch background (at
least one parent born outside the Netherlands). Of the total female population of
Amsterdam, 50 per cent has a non-Dutch background, so non-native women are
underrepresented in the research group (Vrouwenemancipatie in Amsterdam
2011). This also holds for single mothers, in that only four of the interviewed
mothers had been divorced. Religious mothers were also underrepresented.
However, as mentioned, ethnicity, religiousness
and the presence of a spouse
were not discriminating factors in selecting the research group, and the aim and
character of the research is not statistical representativeness.
Within the research group, 23 mothers were highly educated (higher
vocational education and university), and 16 lower educated (intermediate
vocational education and lower). Ten mothers were full-time homemakers, eight
mothers had a small part-time job (12 to 24 hours), eleven mothers had a large
part-time job (25 to 35 hours) and ten mothers worked full-time.
Interview questions
The interviews can be characterised as oral life history interviews (Bryman,
2008). The interviewees were invited to look back at specific moments in their
lives,
especially during childhood, while also concentrating on the behavioural
steps of later social life, from finishing high school, choosing a continuation
course, entering their first job and giving birth to their first child. While focusing
on these specific life moments, mothers were especially encouraged to consider
the presence of supportive ‘others’ who had possibly encouraged them in
developing their professional lives.
The interviews were built on several central themes:
gender attitudes, work
attitudes, parental socialization, and the influence of significant others. Several
open questions were asked in order to discover how and with which words
women refer to these themes themselves. Iterative cycles formed the base of the
research.
Personal gender attitudes refer to a mother’s desired division of labour with
her own spouse. This personal ideal was more closely examined by mother’s
satisfaction with her current division of labour. A traditional personal gender
attitude means a desire to have the
main responsibility at home, while her partner
is in paid work. An egalitarian personal gender attitude implies a wish to share
paid and unpaid work equally. Adaptive attitudes are here defined as the personal
desires to combine paid work and family tasks, with consent to the idea that
mothers have more responsibilities at home and fathers may work full-time. (Do
you have ideas about the ideal division of labour with your spouse? Are you
satisfied with your own current division of labour? What would you like to
change?). Also some questions were asked about her general ideas about the ideal