Chapter 7 - Exploring the social biographical patterns of Dutch mothers’ attitudes
173
division of labour between men and women. Questions towards a mother’s
general gender attitude were: How do you perceive differences between men and
women? Do you have an opinion about full-time working mothers or mothers
who are not employed?
Personal work attitudes are defined as mother’s personal motivations to
pursue paid work. (What are the most important reasons for you to work? Did
you have ideas about your future profession at a young age?). A strong personal
work attitude means that someone was already as a young adult strongly oriented
to pursue paid work and is intrinsically motivated to work.
Following this, the mothers were asked several questions about their family
backgrounds, looking back to when they were 12 years old. In particular, this
included questions addressing the gender division of labour of their parents (Did
your parents work? Did your father help with household chores and childcare?
Were your parents happy about their division of tasks?), parental attitudes (What
were the important norms, values, and (implicit and explicit) messages that were
transmitted by your parents?). In addition, several
questions were asked on
upbringing matters, like whether the parents were strict or encouraged their
daughters to fulfil their full potential at school or at work.
Finally, several questions were asked about how mothers perceived their
attitudes and behaviours to have been influenced by teachers, partners, close
friends, people at work, specific role models or others, in fulfilling their full
professional potential.
Interview analysis
The research was specifically sensitive to perceiving the lives of the respondents
in terms of continuity and process, especially referring to the theoretically
assumed continuity throughout the course of life between primary
and secondary
socialization processes (Berger and Luckmann, 1967; Bandura, 1977). Therefore,
the interview transcripts of each respondent were not cut into different codes, but
kept as close as possible to each story told by the respondents.
The main part of the analysis consisted of searching for sensitizing concepts
that could be used as pegs to describe the central narratives of, and the similarities
within, the different groups. The sensitizing concepts were: ideals and acceptance
towards the marital division of labour, importance
of economic independence,
parental roles, positions, messages and attitudes, presence or absence of
stimulating parents and significant others towards mother’s professional life.
Following this, the transcripts were reread while focusing on these sensitizing
concepts, and memos were written throughout the process.
Below, the findings are described along the two research questions, while
attention is given to the sensitizing concepts. The narratives of mothers’ attitudes
could be patterned along two groups: traditional-adaptive attitudes versus
egalitarian attitudes. The differences between these groups are specifically
addressed. When this study refers to a “majority of women”, “most”, or “women
Socialized Choices - Labour Market Behaviour of Dutch Mothers
174
in general”, as a rule of thumb this means that the observation applies to at least
three quarters of the interviewed women within one group. There were also
exceptions in each group, which are described where relevant.
7.7 Findings
Can the origins of a mother’s personal gender and work attitudes be found in
the conduct and attitudes of her parents?
The findings indicate that the origins of Dutch mothers’ current gender and work
attitudes can be found in the way they have been brought up. In particular, the
associated mental symbols – intentionally and unintentionally – transmitted by
the mothers’ mother, seem to have a differentiating effect on mother’s current
attitudes. In this study, mothers with traditional or adaptive
attitudes often have
no job, or else work small part-time jobs. They tend to perceive it as their natural
role to execute most of the unpaid family tasks, and do not put much value on
their economic independence. They also appear mostly satisfied about the
division of the work at home with their partners, which is often around 80 per
cent of the tasks for the mothers and 20 per cent for the fathers. Mothers with
more egalitarian gender attitudes, who often have large part-time or full-time
jobs, cannot imagine
not working themselves; moreover they consider it as
unwise, citing the necessity of economic independence. They also expect a more
equal share from their husbands in the unpaid tasks at home, which full-time
working mothers have greater success in achieving.
Mothers with traditional or adaptive gender attitudes generally emphasise that
they come from warm families, and often have many happy memories from
youth. Consistently, the relationship with their parents often is still close. On the
question of who is a shoulder to lean on when they must make
a difficult
decision, traditional or adaptive mothers most often recall their parents.
The parental division of work used to be traditional, not because their mothers
did not work, but especially in the sense that their mothers unquestioningly did
most of the unpaid family work. The presence of a caring mother, who carried out
her unpaid duties without complaint, is recollected as a natural and self-evident
situation by their traditional or adaptive adult daughters. Sometimes, the
interviewees have no clear memories of their mother during primary school. Yet,
mostly they presume that their mothers liked their role
of child carer and
housewife, although they admit they never really asked their mother. Respondents
recall that their fathers pursued full-time jobs, and often also at home were also
the boss.
“My mother did everything. I found that normal. I cannot remember her
complaining about it, or that she found it too much work or too busy. I think
she enjoyed it, I have never asked her, to be honest. My father was just an