13
PLUTONIUM
2. RELEVANCE TO
PUBLIC HEALTH
osteosarcomas) were the primary cause of cancer deaths in dogs exposed once to
238
PuO
2
aerosols; lung
tumor incidences were also relatively high in these dogs, and liver tumors appeared to be a contributing
cause of death in a few
238
PuO
2
-exposed dogs. The pattern of tumor development in dogs exposed to
239
Pu(NO
3
)
4
was similar to that of dogs exposed to
238
PuO
2
, with tumors observed in lung, bone,
and liver
(principally of bile- duct epithelium). Bone tumors were the main cause of death in the exposure groups
with mean initial lung burdens of 1 and 5.9 kBq/kg. In contrast to the high incidences of bone tumors in
the dogs exposed to
238
PuO
2
or
239
Pu(NO
3
)
4
aerosols, cancer deaths in dogs exposed to aerosols of the
relatively insoluble
239
PuO
2
were predominantly associated with lung tumors consisting mainly of
papillary adenocarcinomas based on a lifespan composite study. Tumor incidences at other sites in the
239
PuO
2
-exposed dogs were not statistically significantly different from those of controls. Earlier and
shorter studies reported bronchiolo-alveolar carcinoma as the most frequently identified cancer type.
Respiratory Effects.
Possible associations between exposure to plutonium and
respiratory tract
disease have been examined in studies of workers at U.S. plutonium production and/or processing
facilities (Hanford, Los Alamos, Rocky Flats), as well as facilities in Russia (Mayak) and the United
Kingdom (e.g., Sellafield). Collectively, these studies have not found significant associations between
mortality rates from respiratory tract disease, other than cancer, and
exposures to plutonium among
workers at these facilities. Possible associations between exposure to plutonium and pulmonary fibrosis
were examined in a cohort of workers (n=326) at Rocky Flats. The study assessed lung interstitial
abnormalities from the most recent available x-rays in relation to estimated lung equivalent dose from
plutonium. Estimated lung equivalent doses ranged from 0 to 28 Sv (approximately 73% <1 Sv). The
odds ratio (adjusted for age, smoking status, and evidence from pleural abnormalities from possible
asbestos exposure) was significant for the dose group 10 Sv (5.3, 95% CI: 1.2–23.4). A report of one
study was based on scoring radiographs for the severity of chest abnormalities considered consistent with
fibrosis, and did not include information regarding a possible association
between these lung
abnormalities and clinical symptoms of disease.
Radiation pneumonitis has been observed following inhalation exposure of dogs, nonhuman primates
(monkeys and baboons), and rodents to plutonium (primarily insoluble) compounds, and was identified as
primary, major contributing, or incidental cause of death in some dogs and nonhuman primates that
inhaled
238
PuO
2
,
239
PuO
2
, or
239
Pu(NO
3
). Results of lifetime studies in dogs indicate that radiation
pneumonitis in the
239
PuO
2
-exposed dogs occurred at lower ILBs and
had a shorter time to onset
compared to
238
PuO
2
- or
239
Pu(NO
3
)
4
-exposed dogs. This observation is consistent with the toxicokinetic
differences observed for inhaled plutonium compounds, showing that inhaled
239
PuO
2
is cleared from the
14
PLUTONIUM
2. RELEVANCE TO PUBLIC HEALTH
lung more slowly than
238
PuO
2
and
239
Pu(NO
3
)
4
. The radiation pneumonitis/pulmonary fibrosis
progressively impaired lung function, including alveolar-capillary gas exchange, resulting in increases in
respiratory rate, minute volume, arterial CO
2
pressure, and lung stiffness, along with decreases in tidal
volume and
arterial O
2
pressure. Increases in radiation dose and dose rate corresponded to reduced times
to the onset of symptoms and increased severity of effects. Radiation pneumonitis tended to be observed
at lower ILBs in the 0.75 and 1.5 µm AMAD groups than in the 3.0 µm AMAD group.
Hematological Effects.
Possible associations between exposure to plutonium and mortality from
hematopoietic diseases have been examined in studies of workers at plutonium production and/or
processing facilities in the United States (Rocky Flats), United Kingdom (Sellafield). Collectively, these
studies have not found significant associations between mortality rates from diseases of blood or blood-
forming organs and exposures to plutonium among workers at these facilities.
Compound- and dose-dependent decreased numbers of selected white blood cells were observed in dogs
exposed to plutonium aerosols. Primary hematological effects following pulmonary deposition of
238
PuO
2
and
239
Pu(NO
3
)
4
were lymphopenia and neutropenia, whereas lymphopenia was both the first
biological
effect to be observed and the primary hematological effect of inhaled
239
PuO
2
. Persistent hematological
effects occurred in
238
PuO
2
- and
239
PuO
2
-exposed dogs with initial lung burdens as low as 0.28 kBq/kg
initial lung burdens that elicited hematological effects in
239
Pu(NO
3
)
4
-exposed dogs appeared to be
somewhat higher (mean initial lung burdens ≥5.91 kBq/kg. For
239
PuO
2
-exposed dogs, the time of onset
for significant lymphopenia was inversely related to dose (112 days, 180 days, 1 year, or up to 5 years for
ILBs of 29, 14, 6.4, and 3.7 kBq/kg lung, respectively). Decreased lifespan was observed, although some
of these dogs exhibited a return to normal lymphocyte counts after 5 years. No changes in
red blood cell
counts were observed through year 7 other than a compensatory increase in animals with pneumonitis or
pulmonary fibrosis. Plutonium accumulated in the lymph nodes of the
239
PuO
2
-exposed dogs, resulting in
lymphoid atrophy and fibrosis, especially in the trachiobronchial region. The lymphopenia was
considered to be the result of lymphocytes being irradiated as they passed through pulmonary lymph
nodes.
Hepatic Effects.
Possible associations between exposure to plutonium and mortality from liver
disease (e.g., liver cancer) have been examined in studies of workers at U.S. plutonium production and/or
processing facilities (Hanford, Los Alamos, Rocky Flats), as well as facilities in Russia (Mayak) and the
United Kingdom (e.g., Sellafield). Collectively, these studies have not found significant associations