Microsoft Word en кд 2017-220-06 (3) 21 04 2016

14

Number of publications (of type 

«article», «review», «book», «book 

chapter») by the leading scientist in 2012-2017 in scientific issues indexed by 

the Web of Science Core Collection database under a research topic 

corresponding  or  adjacent  to  the  research  topic  of  the  application  for 

the competition

9

.

 

0-100 

14.3.

 

As a result of the first stage of evaluation, a rating is formed in which application for 

participation in the competition are placed in descending order according to points they 

accumulated.

 

According to the formed rating the Council makes the decision to promote some of the 

applications to the second stage of the evaluation process.

 

Information concerning the applications for participation in the competition that were 

promoted to the second stage of the evaluation is published at the Designated website of the 

Program within two workdays after the protocol is compiled for the Council meeting during 

which the corresponding decision was made.

 

14.4.

 

The following criteria are used for evaluation of applications at the second stage of the 

evaluation process:

 

№ 

Criterion 

Comment

Points

1 

Scientific reputation of the leading scientist and key member of the 

research team

0-55 

1.1 Scientific achievements 

and level of scientific 

publications of the 

leading scientist in the 

selected direction of 

scientific research 

Level of scientific results of the leading 

scientist, their adequacy with the world-class 

level in the selected direction. Publication 

activity of the leading scientist and rankings of 

scientific issues in which the leading scientist’s 

paper are published; adequacy of the level of 

those scientific issues and publication activity 

with leaders of the selected direction of 

scientific research; scientific awards and medals 

won by the leading scientist 

0-25 

1.2  Experience of the leading 

scientist in managing 

scientific teams and 

training personnel 

Administrative experience of the leading 

scientist in creating world-class research teams 

(laboratories, research groups etc); experience of 

working as chief of scientific projects; doctors 

and candidates of sciences prepared under the 

command of the leading scientist; experience in 

teaching in leading Russian and foreign 

universities 

0-15 

1.3 Scientific achievements 

and level of scientific 

publications of the key 

members of the research 

team 

Qualification and publication activities of the 

key members of the research team; their role in 

conducting the scientific research project 

0-15 

2 

Scientific research project

0-25

2.1  Relevance of the planned 

scientific research project 

and significance of 

expected results for 

priority directions of 

scientific and 

technological 

Relevance of the planned scientific research 

project and its adequacy with the modern state 

of world science; possibility of achievement of 

new, breakthrough scientific (and technological) 

results and their importance for priority 

directions of scientific and technological 

development of the Russian Federation and 

0-15 

---

15

 

development of the 

Russian Federation and 

meeting major challenges  

meeting major challenges; demand for results of 

the scientific research project on the scale of  

world science (economics).  

2.2  Proposed approaches for 

achieving declared 

results of the scientific 

research project, 

feasibility of the 

proposed scientific 

research project 

Level of novelty of approaches and methods for 

solving the stated task, their adequacy with 

common practice around the world; level of 

detail and accuracy of the scientific research 

plan, its feasibility within the set time limits 

using proposed methods; adequacy of the 

requested amount of funding 

0-10 

3 

Organization’s obligations to create a laboratory

0-20

3.1  Practicality of creation of 

a laboratory in the 

selected direction of 

scientific research 

Practicality of creation of a laboratory in the 

selected direction of scientific research 

0-5 

3.2  Plan for creation and 

development of a 

laboratory 

Level of detail and feasibility of the plan for 

creating a laboratory within the project for the 

medium term including obligations of the 

organization to supply necessary room for the 

laboratory and conducting scientific research, 

equipment at the laboratory etc. 

0-5 

3.3 Obligations of the 

organization to 

additionally finance the 

laboratory 

Amount of funding from the organization that is 

additionally allocated for creation of the 

laboratory and conducting the scientific research 

project 

0-5 

3.4.  Supply of housing for the 

leading scientist for the 

period of the scientific 

research project 

(including using funds 

from regions of the 

Russian Federation) 

Quality, type (room, apartment or other), 

distance from the workplace and presence of 

necessary infrastructure of the housing supplied 

to the leading scientist for the period of 

conducting the scientific research project. 

0-5 

 

14.5.

 

To evaluate applications on the second stage an evaluation procedure is set up in the way 

prescribed by the Order No 568 of the Ministry of Education and Science of Russia of 

26 May 2010.

 

Expert decisions provided as a result of the evaluation procedure are sent by the competition 

commission to the Council which determines the winners of the competition.

 

14.6.

 

The Council determines the winners according to the results of the expert evaluation 

procedure before 15 November 2017. 

 

14.7.

 

Information concerning the results of the competition will be published on the Internet at the 

official website of the Ministry of Education and Science of Russia and on the Designated 

website of the Program, as well as in the media. Only information relevant to participants of 

the competition will be published.

 

 

15.

 

 Signing a grant allocation agreement

15.1.

 

A grant allocation agreement is signed according to the results of competitive selection 

within 30 workdays of the moment of publishing of the information concerning the results 

of the competition at official website of the Ministry of Education and Science of Russia 

and on the Designated website of the Program. 

 

If necessary, the Ministry of Education and Science of Russia can extend the period of 

signing grant allocation agreement for up to 20 workdays. Notification on extension of grant 

---