Chapter 8 - Synthesis: overview and discussion
187
norm
49
and perceived behavioural control
50
(Ajzen and Fishbein, 2005, p.194).
Sociological empirical researchers have demonstrated the value of including
women’s gender and work attitudes in explaining their labour market behaviour
(Beets et al., 1997; Hakim, 2000; Hooghiemstra, 2000; Marks and Houston
2002a; Portegijs et al., 2008b; Risman et al., 1999) and yet generally these studies
have not included the possible intermediating effect of intentions (defined in this
study as work preferences) between attitudes and employment decisions.
51
In this
study, it is argued that gender and work attitudes are closer (but not identical) to
work preferences than to behaviour. The first aim of this study is therefore to
disentangle the separate roles of attitudes
and work preferences in the
employment decision-making process.
The second theoretical notion of this study is the assumption that the
employment decision-making process is socially formed and embedded. Labour
market activity is understood as an outcome of a process that consists of
consecutive decision-making moments, like dependent paths: each successive
step depends on previously taken decisions. Attending school, whether as a high
achiever or not, taking erroneously or correctly chosen continuation courses, and
then the ensuing steps taking into professional work, are all not facts that can
easily adjusted or reversed. Most people experience
the consequences of each
educational and occupational step taken throughout their life. Besides being based
on personal characteristics and structural circumstances, like the availability of
financial support, studies and jobs, these important steps forward are all partly
based on peoples’ values
and attitudes, and their subsequent work preferences.
People have developed these values and attitudes through the exposure to and
internalization
of parental behaviour, norms, values and attitudes, especially
during childhood (Bandura, 1977; Berger and Luckmann, 1967; Handel, 2006).
Experiences and social interactions in later life can change the intensity of these
values and attitudes, however the underlying assumption is that values and
attitudes are not easily modified in opposite directions,
because individuals
generally like their identity to be confirmed, and significant others are salient for
this ongoing substantiation of their identity (Berger and Luckmann, 1967, p.170).
Nevertheless, it is not only important to understand
that values and attitudes
have been formed, developed and sustained within different social relational
contexts. The motivation for this study is also to understand
how social
backgrounds and networks have influenced the career-relevant attitudes and
preferences of mothers, and
which values and attitudes, that have been
transmitted and sustained, are important in understanding mother’s labour market
behaviour. Put differently, more needs to be known about the nature of micro
49
A person's expectation of social approval or disapproval of the specific behaviour.
50
A person's feeling of being able to enact the specific behaviour, which is related to the supposed
ease or difficulty of
performing the behaviour
51
Work preferences are in this study measured as the number of hours a mother wants to work.
Socialized Choices - Labour Market Behaviour of Dutch Mothers
188
socialization processes that may have mediated or regulated Dutch mothers’
diverse work preferences.
The central question of this research is:
Can specific (micro) socialization processes explain the current differences
among Dutch mothers’ gender and work values, attitudes and work
preferences, and how, in turn, do work preferences affect mothers’ labour
market behaviour?
The answers to this question are elaborated in this chapter through the four
hypotheses of the study. The aim of the synthesis, besides summarising the most
important findings of the study, is also to confront the
similarities and differences
of the qualitative findings and the quantitative results, while addressing the merits
and limits of both research methods. The four hypotheses tested in this study are:
1.
A mother’s labour market behaviour is based on her preferred number of
work hours.
2.
A mother’s preferred number of work hours is influenced by her general
gender values and personal gender and work attitudes.
3.
A mother’s general gender values and gender and personal work
attitudes are influenced by parental socialization during childhood.
4.
A mother endorses more egalitarian values and attitudes if she has
perceived the professional and career support of significant others.
8.2
A mother’s labour market behaviour is based on her preferred
number of work hours
The first aim of this study was to disentangle the separate role of diverse work
preferences (preferred number of work hours) in explaining mothers’
heterogeneous employment decisions. The labour market behaviour of mothers
can be divided into the number of hours that mothers work and the participation
decision of whether to work or to stay at home. The expected relationship
between work preferences and labour market behaviour has similarities with the
theory of planned behaviour of Ajzen (1991) and Azjen and Fishbein (1973,
2005). This theory assumes intention to be an aim that guides action to perform a
particular behaviour, and that intentions are based on a person’s attitudes,
expected approval of significant others, and perceived ability to perform the
behaviour. The stronger the intention to engage in particular behaviour, the more